5.0 out of 5 stars
Beautifully crafted, a joy to read, Nov 10 2003
This review is from: Emerald City: Stories (Paperback)
I'm a writer. I've heard Jennifer Egan speak, and I know her background and history. You guys are as far off-base as you could possibly be.
Pay no attention to the negative reviews. How seriously can you take, for example, someone who can't distinguish between an author's own politics and those of the characters about whom she writes? And yes, she has academic training -- but her fiction was shaped by her experience as a struggling young writer in New York. And finally, the dozen-and-a-half reviews excerpted in the edition I have include raves from the NYTBR, Time, The Phila Inquirer, The SF Chrnoicle, etc -- who are you going to believe? NYTBR or some anonymous bozo on Amazon?
Buy it -- you will absolutely not regret it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Good writing by an author stuck in gender myths, May 10 2002
This review is from: Emerald City: Stories (Paperback)
It's true, Jennifer Egan is a good writer. She's descriptive and eloquent. The problem is, her characters are all the same and her view on the world is, quite bluntly, annoying and misleading.
The majority of the female characters in this book are whimps who have things done to them. They're victims. Sure, a lot of them are scruffy "survivors," I'll admit as much. But none of these women are really proactive or, for that matter, perpetrators, at least not on par with the men in these stories.
One example where Egan has the "victim" thing really messed up: Reliable studies have shown that the "First Wives Club" mentality is a myth. The majority of men do not leave their wives for prettier, younger trophy wives. About 2 thirds of all divorces are actually instigated by the wives. The men don't come out smelling like tulips here, however. A large percentage of wives ask for those divorces because they're tired of being super moms or having to take care of their husbands like they're children. The point is, a lot of women take charge of their lives and are not victims! As for most men, the idea of a young pretty second wife is typically, in reality, the thing of fantasies.
Egan needs to wake up to the world and understand that people are just people. Men get cheated on, women get cheated on, sometimes you're victim, sometimes you're the perpetrator. This book might be eloquent, but it's also a victim's propaganda -- one that perpetuates myths and adds fuel to the "gender war" instead of adding to our understanding. Please, Ms. Egan, get some objectivity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Just Right, July 19 2000
This review is from: Emerald City: Stories (Paperback)
I read this slim volume of stories with a sense of awe. Each story is like a jewel set in an elegant bracelet. Egan's prose is crystal clear yet subtle. Her characters are so alive, so fatally human. Each story veered away from what I expected, but surprised me with how "right" they ended. Although these tales are conventional short stories, each of them had the clarity of a fine poem yet the depth of a novel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No