1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
A little better than "Battle School," but that's not saying much., April 12 2011
By Braden E. Bost - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Ender's Game: Command School (Hardcover)
Maybe it's because it's actually a little better. Maybe it's because I read this weeks after reading "Ender's Game," whereas I read "Battle School" only days after finishing it. The story still feels rushed like a bad Michael Bay movie, but not as rushed as the first one. Though, again, I knew what was going on only because I'd read the novel. That's what this is really for: you've read the novel, now here's someone's vision of it. It's a little fun to see the story--the Dragon Army battles, the fight with Bonzo, the conversation with Val on the lake--but that's it. Don't expect any real substance from this.
It hits all the big story points, but completely leaves out the Locke and Demosthenes subplot and the entire epilogue. You are also shown that Bean is important, but not ever shown why as you are in the book--but there's a graphic novel adaptation for "Ender's Shadow," so maybe they explore it more there . . . but then again, if these two books are any indication, they won't. As with the first one, too, the art is fine, but its still obviously done lazily on a computer, re-using some drawings and zooming in on them rather than drawing a whole page. The drawings are well done and they're interesting, sure, but c'mon. These aren't very long graphic novels, don't make them look so rushed.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great addition to Ender saga, Dec 6 2011
By author111 - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Ender's Game: Command School (Hardcover)
Librarians have access to all thing written. I don't remember what led me to Ender's Game back in 1992 but I've been astounded by every addition to the tale that began as a short story. Card's descriptions are rich, but I was delighted to see them realized in graphic novel form, pretty much the way they appeared to me. I would hope that anyone finding the graphic novels first would also dive into the books they are derived from, thus enriching their understanding of Ender's world.
4.0 out of 5 stars
Best adaptation ever!, Feb 21 2011
By Federico Vaz "Fedezx" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Ender's Game: Command School (Hardcover)
I know my opinnion won't be as objective as it should, because I'm a big fan of OSC's work.
Anyways, Pasqual Ferry's pencil is just sublime, for not mention colour work.
I didn't knew Marvel's Premiere Editions, but those editions are worthy of every single cent.
I would recommend it!