Most helpful customer reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
Very realistic, Nov 4 2001
I liked this book because it was so realistic, and the characters so ordinary (I like plain and ordinary things). I especially liked the ordinary-ness of the adult romantic relationships, such as the portrayal of sex between loving married partners with 3 active kids. However, this book lacked the "oomph" that would make me go back to it again and again. There is no deeper message to it than simple storytelling. It's a good read for passing the time, not for discovering humanity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Sad, but barely there, Jun 4 2000
I picked up this book because I had been so stunned by the skill Judith Guest exhibited in 'Ordinary People'. But apparently she's grown much more tolerant of flaws in her writing since then. This book reads like it was totally unedited. While normally I am a patient reader, halfway through the book I just put it down and couldn't bring myself to pick it up again. Is it mature? Yes, yes, yes. Kindly refrain from bombarding me with indignant comments to the effect that Guest's writing has *matured* since 'Ordinary People'. Perhaps it has. But it takes more than maturity to make a good book. First of all, take the characters. Is there even a single distinctive or memorable one in the lot? Kenneth draws the most sympathy from the reader, because he is dying, and because the moments within his head when he is trying to sort out the meaning of his own existence are beautifully written. But even so, the fact that he is dying is his most outstanding characteristic. When he dies, the sense of loss is acute, and very well expressed. Unfortunately it is not enough to carry the book. Annie and the kids are, to be honest, rather dull. Their personalities are stereotyped, especially Harry's--another teen-deprived-of-father-figure delinquent for the ages. In general, people in this book seem to be defined by their problems, instead of being defined by genuine personalities. What really turned me off this book was the dialogue. Dialogue has many purposes: to inform the reader about the speaker's character, or to further the plot, to contribute to atmosphere, to set the tone....none of these things are accomplished in the useless lines put forth here. It sounds like the author wrote down everything everybody said at her own family picnic--no matter how boring or pointless--and made a novel out of it. Certainly the mundane is an essential fact of existence. But why dwell on it to the point of insanity? I find it more inspiring to wash dishes than to read dialogue like this, because at least I'm accomplishing something. If it hadn't been for the popularity of 'Ordinary People', I doubt this book would have been published without serious reworking.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Life's Errands, Aug 27 2001
When so many novels scoot by on waves of glitz and style, Judith Guest's "Errands" moves slowly, deliberately through the daily life of a family in Michigan. There are no movie stars, power brokers or politicians here. The characters are, as her previous novel was titled, "ordinary people" living ordinary lives. The critical event of the novel is the fatal illness of Keith, husband to Annie and father to Harry, Jimmy and Julie. Annie is strong, so strong that she cannot let herself be taken under by the grief and anger that well up inside her. So she holds herself straight, takes a job, snaps at her children, and keeps going. Meanwhile, the children fall apart, each in his or her own way. Annie's sister, Jess, watches the family's ordeal. And she steps in when she is needed, while trying not to push too hard. She has her own problems, emotionally thrown by her intense love affair with a married man. In the hands of another writer, Annie would be a very unsympathetic character - cold and aloof, demanding from her children the same stoic strength she requires of herself. Yet Guest is able to show us the suffering inside Annie, and how she tortures herself more than anyone else as she tries to hold on to sanity in the only way she knows. This book is not a quick read, but a thoughtful, powerful and moving experience. The beauty of Guest's writing lies in her willingness to look at everyday life and accept it, believe in it. She shows that how we face and deal with the real challenges of life is what matters in the end.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|