Most helpful customer reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
Who am I?, Jun 24 2004
This, in my honest opinion, is Caroline B. Cooney's best novel to date. It received the most recognition out of all of her work and began the quartet of Janie books. The plot, prior to my first reading of this in the 5th grade, was something I had never heard of before. 15 year-old Janie Johnson is living the life of an average high schooler. She has a fiercely loyal best friend named Sarah Charlotte and a group of friends to eat lunch with. More and more feelings are stirring within her for shaggy-haired Reeve, who is potential boyfriend material. She has two loving parents who have loved her since birth. Or so she thought. One seemingly regular lunch period, Janie notices a picture of a random missing child on Sarah Charlotte's milk carton. But the 3 year-old toddler in a polka dot-adorned dress isn't all so random after all. That little girl, Jennie Spring, is her, Janie Johnson. Memories of the very same dress arise. Now, Janie is faced with two choices. She can either try to uncover this harrowing mystery herself - are her parents really kidnappers? Who are her real parents? Or, she can confront the husband and wife she has been living with for as long as she can remember. Well, almost as long as she can remember. Janie chooses the latter over the former. Either way, she must face the undeniable truth, as difficult as it may seem. Cooney's novel about a teen girl amidst an identity crisis is fast-paced and will keep you guessing till the end. Upon first read, I was disappointed that Janie did not get in contact with her biological family, the Springs. But what I hadn't realized was that Janie's ordeal wasn't ending - in fact, it was just beginning. Cooney's writing style was very enjoyable - even these seemingly unbelievable events seemed believable and frank because of the fashion in which she writes, which includes amazing insight into Janie's mind. The YA crowd is in for a treat!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Favourite Since I Was Young, Feb 2 2005
By A Customer
This review is from: The Face on the Milk Carton (Hardcover)
I first read this book when I was in grade 5, about 5 years ago. I loved it! I bought the whole collection and I read them over and over again. A must read for any mystery or thriller lover! One of Cooneys best!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Missing, July 4 2004
No one ever likes to look at the pictures, of the missing children on milk cartoons. With reality crumbling around every one else in the world. Sickening lessons of cruel people. Are not exactly the kind of thoughts people enjoy to think about. However, Fourteen year old Janie Johnson. Will soon learn about one of the horrors of the world. One day while eating lunch with her friends. Janie sees an erie photograph of a three year old with tight pigtails. While staring at it Janie realizes that it is her. A three year old girl named Jennie Spring had been kidnapped at a shopping mall in New Jersey, twelve years ago. Janie had all ways felt something off with her parents. She all ways felt like she never really looked like them. Her mom was often funny when it came to medical papers, and letting her learn how to drive. Now as Janie starts to learn the horrible truth of her childhood. She soon learns what happened between the time she was three years old and now.
Why her parents do not have any photos of her as a baby. Why they have no cloths for her when she was a baby. Janie learns that she is not a Johnson at all. But a completely different girl, who she hasn't been for twelve years.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|