Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Realistic police procedural novel, Nov 6 2009
This book is definitely different from the police novels I've read in the past. The majority of the ones I've read had been rather fast paced filled with lots of intrigue and twists that I'm racing through the novel at an alarming rate. This one was very different. It wasn't fast paced but it was steady and although a little slow at times, it actually got me interested as the criminal investigation went on. It was a gradual procedure, and not one that would take overnight to solve. It had its exciting moments, but moments where you had to sit down and reflect as to what was going on, and it was a much different kind of police procedural novel I have ever seen so far. It was a good balance of careful analysis and examination mixed with intrigue and action. The plot did a good job of drawing you into the crime and having you also reflect and examine on how to solve it. I felt just as frustrated like Kurt was feeling when it felt as if he kept on reaching dead ends and cold trails that would lead nowhere in solving the crime.
The thing I liked the most was the character in Kurt Wallander. He's very real and three dimensional. He had his own issues to solve and it involved a total different story arc on its own aside from the murder case so you're not entirely focused on the mystery. You also got to see the "human" side of Kurt as well which I enjoyed and very much liked. It gave the story a much more realistic feeling to it and not something sensation or "Hollywood" about the entire plot. Kurt had his own faults too and so did his colleagues. I also liked how the story also focused on the secondary characters as well (especially his partner Rydberg, who also has major problems of his own). It was great to see realistic almost "fleshy" characters in the book.
I guess what I didn't really like was I'm not used to this style of writing, so I was really expecting this big flash bang sensational ending where I would be left speechless. This book isn't meant to be that way. The case was closed, and solved and that was that. No big gunfight. No SWAT team. No hostages. No Channel 6 news helicopters flying overhead (har har). It was simple, clean cut, and done. Then again the entire book was like that; clean and to the point. It was like one giant puzzle being put together and having the satisfaction of having it completed on time. Nothing celebratory or excitement just job done, go home and relax. I suppose that's how it's really done and if so, then it's another good job at keeping the story realistic.
Would I read the books following this? sure, why not? it's a short read and I don't regret picking this book up. Although it's not exciting as I hoped it would be, it held my attention enough to keep me going, as I was curious as to who did it and why. Secrets were exposed, and closure was met, and all loose ends were tied. It was well done and complete.
Overall, don't be looking for grand excitement in this one. Just a good realistic police detective novel. It's realistic, and interesting as it takes you along a journey through Sweden and their way of life. It's definitely worth giving it a try if you're up for something mellow and a more on the serious side of the police force.
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Policeman's Lot is Not A Happy One, Jun 1 2004
It is always fun to find a new author to enjoy. I discovered Henning Mackell while discussing books with a friend who's reading interests are even more divergent than mine over cocktails in Bermuda. Not only did she suggest I read the author, she gave me the book to read the next day. A day and a half later I was a fan.Kurt Wallender is not your typical police detective and this is not your typical whodunit. It starts with a next door neighbor in a farming community noting that the sound of the night was different. The next door neighbor's horse was not whinnying. Looking more closely it appearred that the kitchen window was open on a very cold night. Looking more closely, it was clear that it was smashed in. Inside he discovers that the couple have been brutally attacked - the husband has sustained wounds that the M.E. says any four kinds of them would have killed him. His wife is alive, but barely. She has a noose arround her neck. Pretty violent stuff for a poor Swedish farming commmunity. Kurt Wallender has his own problems. His wife has left him. His teen age daughter has gone also. He is drinking too much and dreaming x-rated encounters with a black woman. He is acting chief and mounts the investigation into what seems to be a random crime with no purpose other than to kill. Despite his personal problems, he is a first rate detective and you are drawn along quite easily into what it must be like to really be in this line of work. It is a profession that has much less glamor than many novels give it, but it is also a profession that has exacting standards, required methods and sometimes when all else fails, luck and hunches help. The news of the case horrifies people and when word leaks out that the wife said the word "foreign" before dying, it opens a dark underside in the Swedish populace. Immigration in Sweden is a hot topic and refugees are held loosely in encampments. Threats start to come in against the refugees. One is assaulted. One is killed and a second hunt begins in parallel with the first. A Swedish KKK is on the loose. This is a well told story which will hold your interest and I suspect also interest you in the sequels which follow with Detective Wallender. What more can you ask for?
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Police Procudural, May 21 2004
I really enjoyed this book. it is a fairly straightforward plot, but it is interesting nevertheless, and not without some twists and turns. character development is good; i certainly cared about Wallander. the best thing about this book is the haunted character of Wallander, the realistic nature of the story and its impact on the characters, a bit of swedish life and culture, and, best for me, its inside account of police procedure. i absolutely recommend this one for lovers of Rankin, Connelly, Connolly, Pelecanos, etc.
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|