This is really sort of sad. The original Fantasia dazzled because it touched so many parts of what we as humans are. The music and themes it used were so incredible and varied. It did segments that not only touched all sorts of people, but touched bases with all the sorts of feelings that we, as people have. This film failed to do that. Virtually all of the pieces gravitated around things and concepts, which is sad, since the first words spoken by the Narrator in the original Fantasia described that some music shouldn't be made to describe a story. Yet, every musical piece in Fantasia 2000 was used in exactly that way. What's worse, most of the animated pieces didn't even really feel that wonderful. The Sorceror's Appretice is always good, and "Firebird" wasn't bad, but many of them were silly and immature, which is incongruous with the peaceful tastefullness of the original Fantasia. Also, as expected, the nudity of the original was dispensed with in the sequel. Obviously, without their artistic sense, Disney didn't know how to deal with that sort of thing. However, it doesn't FEEL like they were being cautious, or even just aiming it at kids. It felt like they were just plain scared. I can't respect that.
Still, all these debacles would only have earned it a 3 out of 5 if not for their central mistake. Big names. Fantasia 2000 shamelessly dragged out Big Name actors and actresses between segments, such as Steve Martin and James Earl Jones, giving them lines that not only were silly, but nearly killed whatever tastefullness might have been left in the film. No one wants to see big name stars introduce musical numbers they know (and for that matter, probably CARE) nothing about, and the only people who WILL be able to look past this are children. This leads me to my opinion that this film was aimed at children, and not, like the first one, at adults.
Say what you want about that. It makes the movie less enjoyable for me.
Clearly, the advanced graphics did nothing to cover the difficulties Disney was having at understanding what makes a masterpiece a masterpiece. As I've said, this film seems to be more aimed at children, and a masterpiece that does not make. For whatever reason, I can imagine myself buying the original Fantasia, but I wouldn't pay 5 dollars for this installment.