Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An outstanding book, April 16 2009
Fire and Fury is a page-turner. The chapters are short, dramatic, and the story builds to an awful climax - the total destruction of Germany. As Hansen says that area bombing was a waste of time, and precision bombing a great success, I don't see how this is fence-sitting. What's more, the author all but calls the area bombing of Germany a war crime, and he is utterly damning of Sir Arthur Harris (hence, the claim made by Pathfinder that the author tries to justify Harris's actions is absurd).
It's true that the conclusion covers all sides of the issues, but some issues are complex. If pathfinder wants simplicity and mindless excitement, he should stick to reality TV. For those of you interested in serious history, this is the best book on the subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent contribution to both the historiography of WWII and the ethics of aerial bombardment, Jun 15 2009
Randall Hansen crafts an impeccible and engaging narrative of the Allied bombing campaigns against Nazi Germany from 1942 to 1945. I am an avid reader of WWII aviation literature and count Hansen's contribution to said literature among the most insightful and well-written accounts available.
Hansen's book not only offers a wealth of research into the actions of Carl Spaatz, Arthur Harris, Albert Speer and other key figures, but it weaves historical facts into a series of compelling and beautifully articulated storylines.
Finally, Hansen's questions about the ethics of aerial bombing campaigns remain salient even in contemporary conflics.
An excellent book; one well-worthy the praise it's received in the media.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Well Writen and Researched; One Excellent Viewpoint. Question: Was Bombing The Then German Enemy a Success? Should We Care?, Jun 12 2009
Professor Randall writes in a popular style for a lay readership about a very complex history that spans a relatively long period of time. He delves into that realm of "what-if" and he leaves many questions as he provides answers.
My opinion is that he has written an excellent overview of a subject that is central to understanding how the world got to where it is today. Total war as it was called was last fought in World War 2 and despite all the battles since, nothing of the same sort has (yet) returned to ravage humankind. Why? Air power has become much too lethal - because of so-called conventional armaments, bombs and of course nuclear weapons.
These changes all happened during the years of escalating air warfare between the so-called Allied and Axis nations (the latter being principally Germany, Japan, & sometimes Italy.) Randall sticks mainly to one aspect of this - the war between the Allies and Germany - fought from 1939 to 1945 - divided after the United States' entry into the war, between the separate British and American air forces. The two air powers took different paths in their bombing philosophies. The British and their original allies (the "Dominions" including Canada, Australia) pursued so-called area bombing which emphasized killing as many Germans while destroying the enemy's war effort. The Americans pursued precision bombing, concentrating at pinpointing industrial targets.
There is much more behind these strategies, tactics, ideologies, objectives and results. Randall writes of the roles of the major personalities, the men and women in the various armed forces, the human and industrial targets, the victims and more. A lot to talk about.
There are inevitable faults that can be found. While he does not appear to miss much, he invariably has to skip over some. Read and decide.
85,000 air force personnel died - in the Allied forces. They included British, Canadian, American, Polish, French and other nations. There was a 50 per cent overall death rate in these air forces.
A suggestion. Read this in conjunction with watching the movie The Memphis Belle* - the picture and book together may enhance ones understanding. Read about The Tuskegee Airmen or see the movie with Laurence Fishburne. There are many other ways to enhance one's understanding of the deep importance of this topic. It was very serious business. Our lives as truly free people depend on it - and what do we really know?
In 1944, my father was a young Hungarian Jew who was picked up by German and Hungarian Nazis, then shipped to the Bergen Belsen concentration camp in Germany. He was later shipped out of there, in mid 1945, to another camp, Therensienstadt in then Czechoslovakia, near Prague. On his way in, the train passed a devastated fire-bombed Hamburg. On his way out, the train passed another destroyed city, Bremen. Randall paints a very clear picture of what happened in these fire-bombed cities. Tens of thousands of "innocent" people died in those cities because of those so-called "terror" bombings which were also possibly strategic missions.
There are movies of the aftermath, following "liberation", of the dead and living at Bergen Belsen - the piles of bodies being shoved into massed graves by construction bulldozers. These movie pictures are readily available to see in any library and on the internet. Tens of thousands died in Bergen Belsen, after(!) the camp was liberated, from lingering starvation and illness.
To prevent that type of wanton and ruthless treatment of other human beings - that was what those air force personnel were fighting for, whether they knew it or not. Or maybe, that wasn't what the war was about? Randall touches on the morality of all this. Not as well as he lays out the facts of the matter. But, he does provide the basis of the various lines of thought.
My father's outbound train to Therensienstadt was strafed by American fighter planes. The Germans didn't mark the cars that contained Jewish prisoners - not that it probably mattered. A well known doctor was sitting across from my dad and that other fellow was literally sliced in two by machine gun fire. My father luckily moved quickly enough and wasn't touched. Once again, he made it. He survived.
He went on to live a full, loving life. He died a few weeks ago at age 85 in Toronto Canada, having raised a family of 3 sons, having started up and run a very successful business for over 40 years.
He was able to live his life and employ hundreds of people, contribute to society and breathe for so many more years. How? By means of a few inches, a lot of luck, American and British air forces waging the good, and much what-if ... he lived to see the Nazi (and Japanese) systems of inhumane end in ignominious death. Never to be revived, we hope.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|