23 of 27 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Who are the real winners and losers in war?, Jan 13 2010
By Jack - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Fire on the Mountain (Paperback)
John Brown is one of the most intresting and lesser known characters of American History. He led an unsuccessful raid on an armory in an attempt to start a revolution amongst slaves. This book tells the story of his success and the dramatic difference in American history and advances in modern technology as a result. It's got great characters and is intresting to anyone intrested in Sci-Fi, American and civil war history, black history, or current race relations.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
A bit disappointed, Feb 4 2012
By Joanne Winchenbach - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Fire on the Mountain (Paperback)
I found the book to be disappointing. My expectation was that the author would go into more detail about how the country and society had developed since John Brown's forces won the rebellion. The description of the historical event was adequate enough, but I felt that I never got a good sense of how the subsequent version of America differed from the current one. There were references to several wars that were fought but no explanation of what had precipitated them or who was on which side. There were references to places like Nova Africa, but again I was never clear what that was - was it the entire country or only one part of it. There were hints that the European and African countries had developed very differently, but again it was only hinted at. Those things would have been the most interesting for me - how would America, and the world, look different if the slave rebellions had been successful. I felt I never got a clear picture of that.
4.0 out of 5 stars
One thing needs explained - Elvis, Mar 31 2012
By I'm a fan! "jewell4" - Published on Amazon.com
Short, fun beach read, you can't go wrong with 99 cents and Utopian revised history.
There are a few things unexplained (precise geography, how technology advanced so fast so quickly, mostly).
Loved the irony of Abe Lincoln, whose mission was to preserve the Union and implement gradual emancipation, has mad him a villain.
Only question for me is why was the mechanic named Elvis Pressley Cardwell (not sure if the last name is correct) - is he supposed to be the "real" Elvis?
Overall, it's an intelligent, fun, interesting read.