Amazon.ca
Canadian filmmaker Deepa Mehta scored some modest successes with a couple of engaging North American comedy-dramas (
Camilla and
Sam and Me) about atypical relationships. With
Fire, the first of three films set in India, she looks at relationships that run counter to accepted mores. The film focuses on two sisters-in-law (Shabana Azmi and Nandita Das) who, living in a crowded household and smothered by lifeless marriages, eventually turn to each other for intimacy. It's a beautiful, interesting drama that benefits from its locale, but Mehta (who also wrote the script) directs with a solemnity--perhaps intended to echo the stifling marriages--that wears thin after a while. And for a story all about repressed emotions and illicit passions, there's little fire in the leads: the turn in their relationship seems to come out of nowhere and their reaction to it is surprisingly blasé. The film attempts a more ambitious approach than one might expect, refusing to entirely paint characters in black and white. As boorish, insensitive and repellant as the male characters can be at times, Mehta evokes sympathy for them too, depicting them as victims of society's constraining expectations.
--D.K. Latta