4.0 out of 5 stars
Intriuging, interesting, and maybe a little too short., May 13 2002
By A Customer
This book is a good read because it's interesting, makes you think, and it's short.
The story is pretty obviously divided into two sections: One which describes a two-dimensional land and its inhabitants, one which describes how these characters react to the realization of a three-dimensional land like our own. The entire book satirically illustrates many social/cultural themes under the pretext of describing this two-dimensional civilization.
The book does an good job of detailing how the characters live and thrive in their two-dimensional world, as well as contrasting how many objects and actions which we take for granted in our world are not feasible in theirs.
Also, the author does a good job of making the reader think about how we perceive our world, as well as how we would see (or not see, as it were) a mythical 4D world. Drawing parallels between how we think about a 4D world and how the main characters think about a 3D world, I think, helps to further enjoyment and understanding of the book.
I usually like short books -- I can get through them, feel like I have accomplished something, and move on to another book. However, I feel this book was a little too short. Just when I was really getting involved, the book ended. I think it could have been taken so many more directions (or dimensions.. ha ha).
Nonetheless, I would recommend this book for anyone who likes to think casually about how we perceive (visually and physically) our universe. Even if you don't like to do that, it's kind of a fun story and a good satire. :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
classic, July 1 2001
By A Customer
This is also available in a Dover Thrift edition, but you can never go wrong with these little pocket books. This puts one in a geometric frame of mind that will make more advanced works on this subject, such as those by Hinton or Ouspensky, more accessible to those without either the visulazation or mathematical abilty to go straight to the deeper stuff.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
A wonderful book containing hitherto unexpected insights, April 11 2001
The justly famous Flatland by Abbott stands out for several reasons
1. Its old Victorian style writing which is written from the somewhat "distant observer" viewpoint with the accompanying Englishness to go with it. It is full of social mores of the time (1884) such as the role of women in society or the very specific roles of the "lower classes" and those of the higher levels of society. Included also in this is the social graces themselves where his "feeling" inserted into the book as a means of differentiating various shapes is really a metaphor for the almost repugnant consequences of a meeting between a peasant and a member of the Aristocracy. As such the book is a superb example of he Victorian Age.
2. Another aspect, maybe not so much mentioned, is the fact that the book presents a fine example of the fact that people are trapped by their own culture/upbringing, this time dealt with through the idea of a 2 dimensional being not being able to comprehend 3 dimensions. Apart from the fact that the mind is not able to get around the concept of dimensions higher than the usual 3 I believe the book was intended maybe even accidently to support the idea of a prison of your own culture. However Abbott goes on to show that people are infinitely adaptable and there are ways to meet these seemingly insurmountable challenges. Again a path breaking book when looked at from this angle, who before Abbott would have considered such a view.
3. Finally the book presents many wonderful examples of the illumination of strange concepts not even considered in ordinary life through the vessel of the trek of the square who attempts to grasp his new world with the aid of a sphere.
A wonderful little book containing hitherto unexpected insights.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No