6 of 7 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Nonsense, Jun 26 2009
By Husam Abu-Haimed - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Forecasting Financial Markets: The Psychology of Successful Investing 5th edition (Paperback)
This book is just an incoherent collection of fancy words and phrases (like crowd psychology, feedback systems, fractals, etc). The book is supposed to show the scientific basis behind technical analysis. But, the reasoning (or lack thereof) is mediocre at best. I got the feeling that the author wants the book to sound scientific without any science.
In certain cases, the book makes conclusions that are absolutely and shockingly false. For example, in page 58, the author makes a conclusion that boils down to this: as you increase the window of a moving average, there will be a very high correlation between the values of the moving average at any two times T and T-1. Hence, the author claims, this (the high correlation) shows that financial markets are predictable!!
This "reasoning" is absolutely ridiculous. Moving averages BY DEFINITION smooth out curves and hence increase correlation between time steps of the smoothed curve. In fact, if the window is large enough the value of the moving average will be approximately constant and that will imply that the correlation between T and T-1 is almost 1. This will be the case for almost ANY stationary data series. Does that make any such data series predictable?! Absolutely not!
18 of 25 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Not helpful at all., April 10 2006
By ServantofGod - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Forecasting Financial Markets: The Psychology of Successful Investing (Hardcover)
Believe it or not, I got to re-read the Foreword and the Introduction to check whether the objective of the book is that of the book title. I must praise the publisher for being able to get the endorsement from Financial Times, The Independent, Futures Magazine and even a Sir in the back cover. However, I really doubt whether those critics (no personal name given indeed) had read the book at all.
As a pro mechanical (using TA with as little personal judgement as possible, vs the large judgement needed of, say, Elliot Wave Theories) trader/CFA/trading book lover I really dislike the book. I admit that I am prejudiced against Cycles/Elliot Wave Theories coz it's nearly impossible to tell what phase/stage of what cycle one is in and thus what high profit probability action one should take, except from hindsight which may already be hundreds of pips away. Pathetically, the key theme of the book, if present, is to provide academic background of various types of cycle theory. Psuedo science/psychology/economics, forgive me.
In case you really want to read something to sharpen your trading/investment edge, I strongly suggest you to give it a pass.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very insightful and helpful, Dec 26 2010
By Not My Name™ - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Forecasting Financial Markets: The Psychology of Successful Investing (Hardcover)
The author uses biology and sociology to create a systems theory for financial markets. It's a great read on the human element in trading. Even if most trades are done by quants and algos, they were human once (joke).