A Foreigner Carrying in the Crook of His Arm a Tiny Bomb Paperback – Jun 10 2010
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
"A Foreigner Carrying in the Crook of His Arm a Tiny Bomb imaginatively portrays the forces shaping contemporary India, and it is a remarkable reader of mass culture and popular narrative forms, of the worlds of Hindi cinema, pulp fiction, sensational journalism, and globalized media. Amitava Kumar's rendering of the Starr Report through the experience of the protagonist, Binod, shows us how a seemingly quintessential American narrative--shaped by domestic politics, the culture wars, and a market-driven media--can travel all the way to Delhi in a 'cheap, pirated version,' and be remade by alternative forms of entrepreneurship." --Siddhartha Deb, author of An Outline of the Republic and The Point of Return "Kumar's searching and humane account of the global consequences of the U.S. "war on terror" gets behind the rhetoric and state public relations campaigns in a brisk but thoughtful narrative. Kumar covers intellectual and artistic responses to American domestic and foreign security policies, including the work of conceptual artist Hasan Elahi, who after being randomly interrogated by the FBI after 9/11, has taken to documenting and uploading to his Web site every move he makes. In his own reportage, Kumar (Husband of a Fanatic) focuses on two legal cases, in whose details, including his own interviews with the defendants, he astutely deconstructs the logic of what he sees as a burgeoning police state and the global order (or disorder) it encourages. The first is that of Hemant Lakhani, a boastful 70-year-old smalltime London clothier arrested in a sting operation delivering a sample shoulder-fired missile to an FBI informant. The other concerns Shahawar Matin Siraj, drawn into a bomb plot by undercover New York police. An arresting and heartrending work of public protest and valuable social analysis, this work contributes forcefully to a subtle, human-scaled accounting of 21st-century geopolitics. " - Publishers Weekly, Starred Review "It is among the accomplishments of Amitava Kumar's new book, A Foreigner Carrying in the Crook of His Arm a Tiny Bomb that it refuses to separate the cultural and the political means by which the War on Terror has been waged. Kumar endeavours to connect not only the tortuous practices common to states fighting terrorists, but also the ways this "war" has been imagined... Alongside his personal encounters with these terrorists, Kumar shows the haphazardly constructed legal cases, the government witnesses, and the clash of half-digested cultural understandings. He peels back the stories that we only know by headlines ... With a novelist's eye and a reporter's doggedness... Kumar makes both a political and legal argument, but also a cultural one. It is to his credit that, while writing a non-fiction book, he acknowledges the power of the imagination - of art - to wrestle into view that which politics works to hide from us. Kumar's work demonstrates that the Terrorist is not a "known unknown": he is both ordinary and comprehensible." - Manan Ahmed, The National "Amitava Kumar has written a unique book. It is ultimately a book about neoliberalism, about the public interest defined as militarism rather than as well-being. It is a book about the imagination reduced to suspicion and fear rather than hope and liberty. It is a book that swells from India to Indiana, depicting the global ecology of antiterrorism."--Vijay Prashad, author of The Darker Nations: A People's History of the Third World "Kumar's book succeeds in lifting some of the fog that engulfs the war on terror. It's a must-read." Shobhan Saxena, The Times of India "An important book... Kumar is able to combine painstaking research, taut pacing, and thought-provoking analysis to produce an outstanding work of nonfiction."--Aayush Soni, Business Standard "Kumar builds, with considerable finesse, a case against the brutality and incompetence of the state, both Indian and American."--Sadanand Dhume, Outlook India "I can't think of a more urgent, important, and necessary book."--Pradeep Sebastian, The Hindu "This is a very important book since it speaks of crimes committed by the State under the garb of tackling terror. Be it the paranoia in the U.S. After 9/11 or in India [after] the 2001 attack on Parliament, liberal democracies, while accusing individuals of moral turpitude, have violated all norms of justice and fair play themselves."--Rahul Pandita, OPEN Magazine "Mr. Kumar's book isn't especially long, but it is a many-tentacled beast. In part it's a deft survey of post-9/11 art, from its fiction and nonfiction to its foreign films and obscure works of performance art. At its heart, however, [the book] is about the ordinary men and women, brown-skinned in general and Muslim in particular, who have had their lives upended by America's enraged security apparatus. Mr. Kumar calls them the "small people," and to them he extends his own impressive and trembling moral imagination... A Foreigner Carrying in the Crook of His Arm a Tiny Bomb carries in the crook of its own arm Mr. Kumar's plaintive appeal. If we're to bridge the perilous divide that separates us from those poor and unnamed people who resent us, we first need to see them, to look into their eyes. We need, Mr. Kumar writes, "to acknowledge that they exist." This angry and artful book is a first step." Dwight Garner, The New York Times "Foreigner is part contemporary history, part investigative journalism, part political treatise, part memoir - and an absolute must-read. My greatest fear is that the readers who most need to read this book will not. Kumar is an excellent storyteller. He's also immensely convincing. Drawing on his vast, voracious knowledge of literature, film, television, and breaking headlines, Kumar makes a case that post-9/11 fear has created a not-so-brave new world of bullies and fools. Moving fluidly between his adopted US home and his birthplace of India - another country altered by concerns over terrorism - Kumar carefully exposes what he sees as the senseless abuse of power justified by the 'war on terror'... Again and again, Kumar makes a case that the 'red zone of a terrorist threat' has blinded post-9/11 courts to blatant injustice, condemnation without evidence, and even torture: '[T]his new definition of public interest, where the argument is made in terms of national security,' writes Kumar, 'will trump all other claims every time.' That national security threat at home, Kumar argues, keeps citizens distracted from the 'greater horror of the other war [in Iraq] from our eyes.'" - Terry Hong, Christian Science Monitor
About the Author
Amitava Kumar is a novelist, poet, journalist, and Professor of English at Vassar College. He is the author of "Husband of a Fanatic," a "New York Times" "Editors' Choice"; "Bombay-London-New York," a New Statesman (UK) "Book of the Year"; and "Passport Photos." He is the editor of several books, including "Away: The Indian Writer as an Expatriate," "The Humour and the Pity: Essays on V.S. Naipaul," and "World Bank Literature." He is also an editor of the online journal "Politics and Culture" and the screenwriter and narrator of the prize-winning documentary film "Pure Chutney." Kumar's writing has appeared in the "Nation," "Harper's," "Vanity Fair," "American Prospect," the "Chronicle of Higher Education," the "Hindu," and other publications in North America and India.
Inside This Book(Learn More)
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
Amitava Kumar's new book zeroes in on some of these specimens of the Global War, and in fine-grained detail examines their deeds, their cases and their role in this ongoing drama. What we learn is depressing-- both for the punishments (and often torture) meted out on individuals whose crimes usually amount to talking big to the wrong people-- and for the mounting evidence that this war is in no way closer to achieving its initial goals than it was on September 12th, 2001.
Kumar's discussion is balanced (he is not always sympathetic to the subjects of his narration) and written in an engaging and accessible style. As in his previous books, Kumar mixes different narrative styles, especially reportage and memoir, and quotes at length from portions of the court documents associated with the various cases.
For anyone wishing to understand the War on Terror in greater detail than what is generally available in the press, this book is essential reading.
Amitava Kumar's book is a brilliant and very accessible transnational study of the victims on both sides of manufactured wars. Connecting imperialism, colonization, insurgency, and growing fascism around the world, Kumar carves out a book that is a deeply personal study of innocent strangers swept up and ensnared in globalized net of entrapment, racism, blind rage, and hatred. Kumar is never a distant observer; instead, he meets with almost everyone he talks about, covering events related to the "war on terror" from the U.S. to India to Kashmir. This is a remarkable book.
His book turns terrorism into a problem of brainwashed, provincial little guys, hapless entrapped merchants, and bureaucratic bunglers. He concedes that some terrorists are dangerous, but bracketing that entire issue, he concentrates on his little guys. Turns out Kumar is fascinated that one of the terrorists in the Mumbai attacks is awe-struck by the opulence of the five-star hotel in which he carries out the killings. This detail preoccupies Kumar and is offered to us as a major revelation about terrorists. What he leaves out is what horrified most others about this attack--that the terrorists used drugs to keep themselves awake so they could maximize the destruction and killing of men, women, and children, that in a huge city like Mumbai they meticulously hunted and killed members of a tiny Jewish community, that they unflinchingly killed children at point-blank range. Given the enormous moral and political complexity of the problem of terrorism, Kumar is entirely disingenuous to suggest that looking at the little guy, the accidental terrorist, we will have understood better what we confront.
I wonder if he had talked sympathetically about one of the "little guys" involved in the 9/11 attacks, instead of the Mumbai attacks, whether his book would have been reviewed in the mainstream press.
If we are getting our legal analysis and "reportage" of the global war on terror from an English professor at Vassar, it shows just how bad things have become. The mainstream coverage of the war on terror has its flaws, but who can seriously say that this is an alternative? The book's claim to offering a "humane" account of the events covers over the superficiality and flawed reasoning in this book. The writing is patchy, the reasoning is flimsy, and the book is simply not worth its cost.