|
5.0étoiles sur 5
PFG & VV...if you've read the book, you know what it means.., Janv. 12 2004
Par Un client
PFG: the writing. Wow. Lush, vivid, rushing forward and pulling you with it...you cannot put this melodrama down. I give it five stars for sheer entertainment.PFG: the characters. Siddons is a great psychological writer. She gives individualistic sketches of several characters that could be textbook, especially the screamingly psychotic sociopath Ruth Yancey-Fox. Yikes. PFG: the first several chapters, describing the Yancey family. It's as perfect as novel-writing can be right up until Ruth is adopted into the Fox family. Then it gets "Gone With the Wind"-y and "Little Foxes"-y. It continues to mesmerize, but is never as good as those first chapters. V.V.: Descriptions of good ol' black folks who still like to dance on the old plantation 'cause they's devoted to their massahs - ugh. Demeaning, stereotypical, crap. Made me want to throw up. V.V.: Rip, the black woman who "knows" the sickie Ruth almost in the biblical sense: we are set up to believe that she has some magical powers to "protect" Ruth's offspring, but in fact she never does do a damn thing to help them. She's always "lookin' out" for her "chirren," but I found that she was basically in collusion with Ruth. It's like the old saying: "If you're not part of the solution then you're part of the problem." She watched Ruth do horrible things, including murder, and never said a word. Her rationalization, at the end, that "Who would believe me?" just didn't cut it. She had power in that household, too. Even if they didn't believe her, she should have had the guts to spill to beans...or the chitlins, or whatever. V.V.: Tying up the whole thing in letters from Ruth at the end was a highly unbelievable contrivance. But by then you were just happy to have the fascinating story end. As good as it is, it gets on your nerves after a while. I found Nell, the final heroine, to be a milksop. But in the end, too, it's a good sister story. If you've ever had a female sibling rival and made up when you found out how sick the grownups were, you'll probably love it. PFG: Painterly descriptions. V.V.: Location, Location, Location. The South doesn't get more nauseating than this.
|