Most helpful customer reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good Packaging Mediocre Content, July 3 2004
The packaging is an eye-catcher. Even the faux newspaper inside is clever. The last chapter is useable for those looking to find ways to sharpen your product's or service's point of differentiation. It's a variation on the SCAMPER technique we teach in our creative marketing conferences. I read about one book a week, and I teach sales and creative marketing to others. From my perspective, the author is a talented person, with an exceptional work history. That's why I'd like to see Seth reach deeper from a content and application perspective. His work offers little that I haven't seen presented or written about before. Also, too many attempts to create his own vocabulary leaves me confused, and often, irritated. The book should have been one chapter long. With the main point being that soft innovations (as compared to actual product or service modifications)allow companies to move quicker and respond more inuitively with the marketplace. It's a good point, and I look forward to better works in the future. If you're an author, get the book (with the cereal box exterior) as a lesson in promotion and packaging. If you're a marketer, first take a look at Meaningful Marketing by Doug Hall and Jeffrey Stamp. Then, get this book so you can say you've read it. While $20 shouldn't set you back financially, you may consider waiting a few months from now to see if this book shows up on Amazon's used book list at a significant discount.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
On-the-edge is far safer than status quo!, July 5 2004
I'm a big fan of Seth Godin. His books Permission Marketing, Unleashing the Idea Virus, Purple Cow, and The Big Red Fez continue impact me on an almost daily basis. One thing I love about Seth is that he persuasively argues that in today's economy thinking on-the-edge is far safer than maintaining the status quo. In Purple Cow, Seth argued that businesses and nonprofits need to be remarkable in order to survive. Being remarkable means that people will tell their friends about your product or service. Purple Cow was a thought provoking book but was lacking in helping readers implement the ideas. Free Prize Inside takes it the next step and shows us how to market and create remarkable changes in our organizations. Free Prize Inside is divided into three sections: • Why You Need a Free Prize • Selling the Idea • Creating the Free Prize A "free prize" is a soft innovation. Seth builds the case for the urgent need of people in all organizations, including nonprofits, to be championing soft innovations. Soft innovations are the "clever, insightful, useful small ideas that just about anyone in an organization can think up." A free prize may seem like a gimmick at first but it actually becomes an essential part of your product or service. We all know what our favorite cereal tastes like, but it becomes irresistible when we see we can get a free prize inside the box. To illustrate his point, Seth is selling the first printing of this book in a special-made cereal box! You can pre-order a copy at Amazon.com. He's convinced that anyone can come up with a free prize inside. The problem comes when we share it with others. Seth says our co-workers or boss, ask three basic questions: 1. Is this idea doable? 2. Is it worth doing? 3. Are you the one able to do it successfully? If they aren't able to answer "yes" to all three questions, they won't join you, and the idea will die. The second section of the book is dedicated to specifically showing us how to keep our innovations alive by championing them and winning the support of others. After all, creating a free prize isn't important if we can't sell it to our organization. The last section is dedicated to creating the free prizes. What would make your organization remarkable? Here Seth introduces his new concept of "edgecraft." He explains, "You're...caught in the center of a web of boring. The goal of edgecraft is to pick an edge (there are hundreds to choose from) and go all the way with it-even a little further than that if you can. Moving a little is expensive and useless. Moving a lot is actually cheaper in the long run and loaded with wonderful possibilities." Donuts are boring but Krispy Kreme found an edge and made them sensational. Netflix did the same with movie rentals. They created a free prize by transforming the rental experience and created a very loyal customer following. The United Way found free prize when they discovered the concept of payroll deduction. Pushing that edge has helped them raised a lot of money! Free Prize Inside is an inspiring and practical way for us to find our organization's edges and push for a free prize. It comes with extensive endnotes that cite Seth's sources, expand on points, and point you to great information on the web. I particularly appreciate Seth's constant attention to the nonprofit sector throughout the book. I highly recommend getting a copy. And, if you order it before it's published in May, you can still get it in a cereal box!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Have you made something remarkable today?, May 27 2004
You only have to watch a five-year-old in the cereal aisle to understand the effectiveness of a free prize. A child will pick the healthiest fiber cereal... as long as the toy inside the box is compelling enough. If free prizes are so effective, why do we abandon the idea when we get down to selling "serious" products? Contrary to what you may believe, the lure of the free prize doesn't diminish as people mature. If it did, no one would buy a Lexus and we would all be content with cell phones that only made telephone calls. So where's your free prize? Whether you sell potato chips of mutual funds, a free prize works to pull customers to your brand. Don't have a free prize yet? Seth Godin will teach you the steps in creating one -- and this isn't a complex process reserved for the most elevated gurus of marketing. I'm not even in the marketing department and I put a few of the tips in the book to the test, with immediate results. Seth guides us through championing an idea (in a way which will succeed) and using edgecraft to make your product or service remarkable in clear, example-filled chapters. The lengthy list of ways in which you can tweak your offering to make it stand out is one that I return to again and again. I have limited reading time, yet I even found myself immersed in the endnotes. There is an idea of value on every page of this book and the cereal box is arrives in will look great on your desk.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|