5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Decent, but flawed look at a complex political era., Jan 11 2007
This review is from: Full Circle: Death and Resurrection in Canadian Conservative Politics (Hardcover)
Bob Plamondon's writing in "Full Circle" is ambitious, and his research is well fleshed out: His list of interviewees for the work is pretty much the Canadian right of centre who's who. Plamondon seems likable, and his writing style flows well as it gets going. It was almost amazing to get a clearer look at the 2003 Progressive Conservative convention, one of the strangest events in Canada's political history. Other areas are covered in depth, with some surprising revelations (For example, an interesting choice for interim leader of the new party that was agreed upon by MacKay and Harper). Coverage of the two recent elections is well done as well.
However, while recommendable, flaws are many. Plamondon is quick to proscribe motives and casts Preston Manning as the villain of the early part of the book, while almost uncritical of the Mulroney government. In fact, besides certain ambiguous assertions, perceived corruption in the PC government is not mentioned as a factor at all behind Reform's rise, when that was one of the major talking points of the era. Mulroney's accomplishments are considered golden, while Manning's amazing journey to create a political movement from near-scratch is given little praise. Peter MacKay seems to get the same fawning praise as Mulroney. While such black and white views work in some places, they don't work in a book like this this one, that is supposed to capture the personalities of the movement.
Also, Plamondon sometimes contradicts himself heavily. In one example, he constantly goes on about "vote splitting" between the Reform/Alliance and PC parties. I wouldn't agree that it was the only reason, or that it gave the Liberals a free ride, but it's a defendable route of analysis. However, he even points out a poll from the 2000 election that vote splitting made a minute difference in the results, and that poll didn't even fully count lost PC voters. However, he continues to chant the "vote splitting" mantra again and again, and doesn't even refute the poll. His treatment of David Orchard also seems like that of two different writers: Through most of the 2003 PC Convention chapter, he's very courteous to the candidate, and says that he got a lot of bad breaks from the party. Strangely, though, the last paragraph insinuates, out of the blue, that he was a Liberal plant, without providing anything in the way of proof besides the fact he joined the Liberals 3 years after the PCs collapsed.
Footnotes are arranged strangely, and some (repeatedly) explain concepts obvious to Canadian political watchers. Speaking of repeatedly, the book constantly goes over facts mentioned earlier, again and again. Not to mention, that at one point (Page 115 of my hardcover edition), Plamondon actually cites Wikipedia. Very, very sloppy. Another warning, and of course not Plamondon's fault: Constant printing errors abound. Many dates are simply listed as 2003 instead of their proper ones.
All in all, "Full Circle" is a decent read and a great way to wrap your head around the many changes of Canada's politics in the last few years. Just don't rely on it for the complete story. And you might want to wait for a future edition.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Manning won't be happy, Feb 22 2007
This review is from: Full Circle: Death and Resurrection in Canadian Conservative Politics (Hardcover)
Bob Plamondon provides an account of the turmoil in Canada's federal conservative parties over the last 20 years that is thorough, opinionated and, for the most part, fair. Preston Manning may not agree that Plamondon is fair; the former Reform Party leader gets a rough ride for dividing the conservative vote and ensuring the Liberals won three consecutive majorities "without breaking a sweat." Joe Clark gets a decidedly mixed review as well.
But Brian Mulroney will love this book. Plamondon is as ecstatic about Mulroney's wisdom, insight and good governance as Mulroney is himself.
While Plamondon's partisanship shows through repeatedly throughout Full Circle, he tells a story that is interesting and full as well as adding some details to the public record of key moments in the lives of the Alliance and PC parties. Well worth reading.
A couple of criticisms. One is that Plamondon does not really seem to have grasped the depth of the Western alienation of the 1970s and '80s that made the emergence of the Reform Party virtually inevitable. Second, the book could have used much tighter editing. For example. Plamondon never seems to have figured out when the word "conservative" -- the most important noun in his book -- should be capitalized and when it should be lower case.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
A bit of a slog - but worth it for the details, May 22 2007
This review is from: Full Circle: Death and Resurrection in Canadian Conservative Politics (Hardcover)
Plamondon's book is based on more than 50 interviews with key players at the time.
Yet,you get the sense he is too close by far to his sources. Consequently, the book can get boring. It reads in some places like simple description, with little or no interpretation and spice.
That is not to say there are not some surprising turns. Plamondon's is strong in his criticism of Preston Manning and his selfish decision to tear apart the Canadian Conservative movement by founding the Reform Party in the late '80s.
Ultimately, Manning is portrayed in a very unfavorable light. He is the lead player in the tragedy of the Canadian Conservative movement's great divide. Manning's great organizational and leadership skills ultimately result in a perverse but very predictable outcome: Two inadequate Conservative parties, and Liberal Party of Canada domination of the Canadian Government from 1993 through to 2006. Plamondon lays the responsibility for this clearly on Manning's doorstep.
The "Full Circle" that Plamondon talks about is the division of the Conservative movement between the Reform and Progressive Conservatives in the late '80s, and the eventual reconciliation between these two camps just prior to the 2004 election leading to electoral victory in 2006. This is a very academic work, but if you can get through the slow parts, there is a lot here that will prove illuminating as the Conservatives prepare for the anticipated election in 2007.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No