2.0 out of 5 stars
The erros never stops!, Sep 20 2003
This review is from: Funk: Third Ear - The Essential Listening Companion (Paperback)
I don't know where to start (the sum-up's in my head...), but let's call it "1" etc...
1.This book features a lot of errors. When covering The Meters, Mr.Thompson first writes that they released 8 albums (which they did), then on the album list there are only seven, and it reads that the song "Hang 'em high" is included on their album "New Directions", which it is NOT (it's on the previous one, "Trick Bag", but that one is left out).
This is unfortunately not the only error; there are hundreds, like some names are spelled differently every other time they appear - E.G.: everybody on earth knows that there are two Rocco's in the world and that one of them plays bass for Tower of Power ...well, every time Rocco Prestia's name is mentioned in this book it reads "Rocca". Incorrect release dates are featured and it says that "One Nation Under A Groove" gave Parliament a spot on the top 20, although it's a Funkadelic album/song.
Another thing I found strange was that the list of artists who has covered Ohio Players' songs are 81, but "Love Rollercoaster" by RHCP's is not included. The story of James Brown firing his band in 1970 just before a show and hiring The Pacesetters the same evening is told three times (when covering J.Brown, B.Collins & M.Parker)!
There are, of course, artists in this book that I am not as familiar with as others, so there may be even more errors than I think. Some are excusable, while others are too big to accept.
2.The reviews is a disappointing feature. The say nothing - they're usually one or two sentences long, not insightful at all. All albums aren't even reviewed. There are unreviewed albums by almost every artist. A track list of all albums would have been a better feature.
3.The stories about the bands are all very basic and they are all written in the same way, "...first the group's name was "this", then they changed it to "that", released this album on this label, then that album on that label, had a hit, then someone quit and four years late they broke up"...it gets tiring.
There are too many bands and artist to cover in 370 pages (not 400 like it says on the amazon page), especially since a fourth of these pages are lists of singles and albums by the artists and long lists of covers by other bands.
It's a pretty misleading dictionary of funk-albums for beginners.
If you want to learn about the music of funk itself, I recommend "FUNK" by Rickey Vincent instead.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Mostly disappointing, April 21 2004
This review is from: Funk: Third Ear - The Essential Listening Companion (Paperback)
I'm familiar with at least half the artists and the albums and the stories this book tells about. Not much is accurate. The writer gives too many personal opinions on the music, many discographies lack important information, the selected sample lists are unnecessary (and take up LOTS of space in the book), and the reviews are uninsightful. Lots of research must've been done in order to get this much "fact" into these many pages, but obviously not enough. Not recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Mostly disappointing, April 21 2004
This review is from: Funk: Third Ear - The Essential Listening Companion (Paperback)
I'm familiar with at least half the artists and the albums and the stories this book tells about. Not much is accurate. The writer gives too many personal opinions on the music, many discographies lack important information, the selected sample lists are unnecessary (and take up LOTS of space in the book)(...). Lots of research must've been done in order to get this much "fact" into these many pages, but obviously not enough. Not recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No