Ghost Story

 

 

Create your own review

It's been at least fifteen years since I read Peter Straub's Ghost Story, and I must admit I've forgotten almost everything about the actual story. What I do remember is my conviction that Straub's novel was truly a masterpiece of the horror genre. Straub is a complete writer, not some penny dreadful hack, and that almost guarantees that no film can possibly do any of his writings justice. Movies revolve around characters and actions, and Straub's fiction really plays on a much higher level. Frankly, I'm surprised that anyone would even attempt to adapt Straub for the big screen. Robbed of its atmospheric build-up, Ghost Story (the film) proves quite incapable of immersing you in the dark shadows haunting the Chowder Club Society meetings. Unable to take on a life of its own onscreen, Ghost Story feels to me like an old made-for-TV movie.

The four elderly, distinguished gentlemen who make up the The Chowder Society have been trading ghost tales and scary stories for decades. For fifty years, however, not a one of them has ever even thought about mentioning the most disturbing story of all, one that they all secretly share. Eva was her name, a saucy little newcomer who had all four of their college-age hearts pitter-pattering as they stumbled over one another pitching woo in her general direction. It's weird enough for four best friends to all be wooing the same girl at the same time, but the director manages to make it even stranger and more confusing. Two of the guys constantly giggle like schoolgirls, none of them seem to have a clue about the essential nature of man-woman communications, and they all combine to make one of the film's most climactic scenes little more than pedestrian in terms of their emotional reactions.

As older gentlemen, the members of The Chowder Society are quite distinguished and refined. It's a solid core of aging actors: Fred Astaire, John Houseman, Melvyn Douglas, and Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. It's rather sad in a way, though, watching true Hollywood greats rapidly approaching the ends of their careers. Astaire's dancing days were long over by this point, but his often-overlooked acting ability is quite evident here - he, Houseman, and a young Alice Krige (Eva/Alma) basically carry the movie on their backs.

Ghost Story isn't a bad movie by any means; clearly, though, it falls far short of the mark set down in Straub's original novel. There's just an almost complete lack of atmosphere on display here, even during the most dramatic scenes. Moving at a preternaturally slow pace, the film will surely turn off a lot of younger fans expecting a lot of in-your-face action from start to finish. It's hard to assign much blame for the ordinariness of this movie, though, as it really comes down to the fact that Peter Straub's fiction just doesn't lend itself to theatrical adaptation.

First, let me say that Straub's novel is one of the finest ghost stories ever written. It's terrifying, too, as good ghost stories should be. Hence, I had high expectations of this film. The fact is the film is dreadful! It's almost nothing like the novel, and the only reason I give it two stars is due to some atmosphere. The cinematography looks good. That's about it. Spend your money, sure, but spend it on the novel and you'll spend many dark evenings in your reading chamber casting furtive glances at those darkened corners.

When I first saw GHOST STORY on its initial release, I found it to be an entertaining, if not faithful, adaptation of Peter Straub's frightening novel. Now, some 20 years later, I found the movie less entertaining. The main problem I think is the enigmatic nature of the ghost, Eva Galli or Alma Mosely. Was she evil or supernatural prior to her death? And why doesn't she kill Donald as she did his brother? Was she really alive when she went down in the car? And what in the world do the Bates have to do with anything? And the classic "I am You" line is powerless without an explanation.
John Irvin's direction is also lackluster and sober. Of all the classic actors involved, none of them showed the power they have possessed in other roles. Although a talented actor, Craig Wasson was woefully miscast. Only Alice Krige as the ghostly Alma and Jacqueline Brookes as Astaire's wife bring any luster or poignancy to the film.
It's not a bad film by any means, and it does have some frightening moments with a wonderful score by Phillipe Sarde. I wish someone would remake it, however, and bring out more of the wonderful scariness of the novel.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 27 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

 

5.0 out of 5 stars Guaranteed To Keep You Awake Late Into The Night ... ...
Universal plans to re-release Ghost Story on September 7, 2004
just in time for Halloween. Most likely this re-release won't have any extras, although we can always hope. Read more

Published on April 27 2004 by Jack Burgess

1.0 out of 5 stars No - No - No - No - No
This is the way you film a very poor adaptation of a well writen and very scary novel.
Here's the problem: Only a very small piece of the storyline from the book made it to... Read more

Published on April 17 2004 by VonLang

2.0 out of 5 stars Best Sex Scene Ever!!!
I haven't seen this movie since it appeared on HBO in the Fall of 1982 but I have fond memories of it. Read more

Published on Feb 1 2004

4.0 out of 5 stars Ghost Story
This is an excellent horror. I've been looking for it for years. More of a good old fashioned horror. I had to own it, there's suspense and the story line is intense.

Published on Sep 2 2003 by kristine f peart

2.0 out of 5 stars Moldy sheets are more frightening.
The Peter Straub novel upon which this movie is based is one of the best and scariest ghost stories ever written. Read more

Published on May 2 2003 by Cody

1.0 out of 5 stars Lame chiller
In "Ghost Story", the old men who make up the "Chowder Society" bide their fading years in a freezing and apparently unending northeastern winter telling each... Read more

Published on Mar 13 2003 by Rottenberg's rotten book review

5.0 out of 5 stars Terrifying
I've read mixed reviews of this horror filck, but I for one, was absolutely terrified. As a huge horror fan, I can safely say that there has really been only one other movie that... Read more

Published on Jan 22 2003 by Nick

5.0 out of 5 stars super dopper
This movie is very good to look at on a cold rainy night, but not by yourself. When I first saw this movie I always remembered the name and I know that I would some day get this... Read more

Published on Nov 19 2002 by Jonina Rogers

1.0 out of 5 stars A Travesty....
Knowing that "the movie is never as good as the book" doesn't help this horrific mess of a film. That being said, I saw the film when it came out 20 years ago, and it was bad... Read more

Published on Sep 15 2002 by Jack-O-Lantern

1.0 out of 5 stars Prancing Poofters On Parade
Even if I hadn't read the incredible book on which this movie is only nominally based, I'd still hate it. Read more

Published on May 1 2002 by Bruce Rux

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 27 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

Search Listmania!