5.0 out of 5 stars
in a very close race for best show on TV, Oct 1 2007
Earlier on,in a review of CSI:Las Vegas, i wrote that CSI may be
possibly be the best show on the air.the only other show which might(i
mean might) be better is the Gilmor Girls.Now it isn't really fair to
compare the 2 shows,since they are not the same genre.CSI is a forensic
crime drama,which does employ dark humour at times.Gilmor Girls is a
drama/comedy,but it uses wit and sarcasm as humour quite often.so i
guess they really are not that similar at all.if you are not familiar
with the show it goes like this:Lorelai Gilmor(Lauren Graham) and her
teenage daughter Rory(Alexis Bledel) cope with life in the small town
of Stars Hollow.i say cope because they live in a town with some very
eccentric,some say odd characters.and there are a few that may just be
nuts.in addition to having to deal with the townsfolk,both also have to
contend with Lorelai's overbearing mother and distant Father,who live
outside of town,but for reasons i won't reveal here,they must spend
more time than they want to with them.Or rather,Loralie must spend more
time than she wants to.there is more to the story than this,but i don't
want to give it away,for someone who has not seen the show.The show was
created by Amy Sherman,who with her husband Daniel also wrote several
of the episodes up to and including season six.this show is amazingly
well written, and the dialogue is truly magnificent.one of the
signature devices in the show is the rapid fire,back and forth banter
between Lorelai and Rory,and the way they communicate with each other
and other people . aside from being witty and sarcastic,is also very
edgy.it deals with some vary serious adult issues at times,and is
sometimes heartbreaking.The other thing Gilmor Girls is known for is
it's pop culture references.each episode is peppered with them,some of
them obscure.if you're not paying attention,you will miss a lot of
them,as they are usually referenced machine gun style,almost as an
aside.also if you not all that into pop culture,you may not get the
references.anyway,the show started off brilliantly and has remained
so.this isn't just a chick show,despite what you may think.Guys will
love it too,though some may not readily admit it.if you haven't seen
it,you should start by picking up season 1,since the storyline has
progressed from each episode.what else can i say
except,awesome,awesome,awesome. 5/5
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 6 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Amy Sherman-Palladino has left the building!, May 9 2007
This review is from: Gilmore Girls: Season 6 (DVD)
I am confused as to how Amazon can be selling this season, when it has not even finished airing yet.
This season is the worst of the 7. Amy Sherman-Palladino, and her husband Dan, left the show at the end of the 6th season, and it shows. The writing is not as crisp or fast paced. The characters seem awkward and stiff. And the storylines are entirely too melodramatic, compared to what the previous six seasons were like.
This season is bittersweet, as it will also be the last season of The Gilmore Girls. I think that Warner did the show a real disservice by not doing all that they could to keep the Palladinos. The show should not have had to end on this bad note.
While the last few episodes of the season have decidely picked up, the rest of the season does not make it worthwhile to purchase. Sales will be based solely on viewer loyalty to a "once" great show.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No