1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic portrayal of boredom in suburbia, May 8 2004
This review is from: Girlfriend In A Coma (Hardcover)
Having grown up in the exact neighbourhood where Coupland sets most of his works, I enjoyed the minute details of this book. Life in the bedroom community of West Vancouver is about as he portrays it. Having this apocalypse set in my own backyard, all of the descriptive tools Coupland use paint a fantastic image of life in a sleepy eutopia.
Struggling to be simply ANYthing is possibly what seperates my Generation-X-ers from most other demographic groups. The relaxed prose of this novel is far more personally gripping then the usual 'hit you over the head with pointless detail' styles you find in far too many contemporary novels. While many find the climax of the story a bit too watered-down, I find that it is an effective tool for describing the feelings of the characters...what IF the world simply ended with a yawn? No big fireworks, no big Michael Bay-style destruction...just simply ended like the batteries running out.
Coupland is apparently not for everyone, but then again who is? Coupland perfectly portrays the generation he represents, and makes no apologies for it. Read this book, read it several times.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
a wonderfully entertaining and uplifting novel, April 7 2002
Girlfriend in a Coma features some rather absurd and quirky plot twists which some readers may find to be a turn off, but Coupland is able to draw the reader into the world of his characters, who he draws out ever so well (Character development is perhaps his strongest aspect.) Before reading this novel I would recommend going back and absorbing both Generation X and Life After God, which are better introductions to Coupland's style. Coupland takes you on a trip to find the meaning of love, life and spirituality in a post-modern world riddled with banal strip-mall landscapes, drug addictions, the accelerated pace of pop-culture, generation gaps, and technological dominance. He gives us human beings still trying to make their way through the world, wondering what lies beyond, fearing apocalypse, seeking love and a self. All in all his works are very amusing, engaging, poignant and thoughtful. He is a master of observation of both the small and grand. I've never read anyone quite like him. (and yes, there are a few Smiths references in the book.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Coupland: Languishing behind the real players., Nov 4 2001
Although I ate this novel up in but a few days, shunning the others I'm currently reading, certain aspects of Girlfriend n a Coma just did not sit right for me. The question is where to begin. Ok, it starts well, we've got a nice little gang of yankee kid pals, the boys, the gals, the charismatic one, the intelligent one, the ditzy one, and for a while there the novel is going just fine. As soon as we hit the actual coma though, Coupland slips from Entertainment mode to Preachy mode.
The suspensions of disbelief we're expected to make with Coupland are a little too much, as the 17 years of Karen's coma are covered in snippets. Are we expected to believe that Richard spends these years thinking only of Karen, not finding one other girlfriend in all this time? The total convenience of having 4 of the already introduced main characters marry each other is a bit hard to swallow, not to mention the small matter of Hamilton and Pam's heroin addiction and overdose. One word: Trainspotting.
Karen wakes up, and it just so happens that she is in position to comment on life in the 90's. Now it's time for Coupland to vicariously put forth his oh so original views through Karen's comments "Everything is about work; work work work" Two words: Fight Club.
Soon the plague rolls around, and Jared the ghost comes back to nauseate the reader with his "miracles" and idealism. Although the group of friends in the book have by this staged reached their mid-thirties, it's difficult to picture them as being out of their teens, as they were when we were first introduced. Jared swoops in, performs a few of the cheesiest miracles ever that made me wanna retch, and then after keeping us waiting for the entire latter third of the book, delivers his Plan B. "Ask questions, no, screech questions out loud. Ask whatever challenges dead and thoughtless beliefs" Instead of thinking "Yes, yes, yes!!", I thought "Pulleeease"
I can't quite put my finger on exactly what pissed me off about this novel, I think the way it quickly descended into nothing more than a overly complex vehicle for the author's opinions, ideals and desires made me feel used. I don't go to church anymore for this exact reason, I don't need to waste my time having someone tell me how the world should be. I find Chuck Palahniuk's method of doing so enjoyable and enlightening, but found this novel nothing more than a saccharine, convoluted morality play.
Maybe I've read too many novels by excellent novelists, but everything about Girlfriend in a Coma reeks of mediocrity. If you're looking for "gritty realism", read Irvine Welsh, for enlightenment, read Chuck Palahniuk, or for a plot tackling none other than the apocaplypse, ghosts and visions read Stephen King, or even Kurt Vonnegut. In short, do not read this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No