2.0 out of 5 stars
For die-hard Tom Wilkinson fans (or Minnie Driver fans), Mar 11 2011
This review is from: The Governess (DVD)
If you can put aside the stuffed dead animals in every room, the grubby-looking sets, the furs, and other "atmosphere" items that make you swear you can almost smell the mothballs and formaldehyde, this is an interesting story.
A young woman, prompted by the sudden and unexpected death of her father, leaves home and takes a position as a governess for a wealthy family who lives in a large house full of secrets. As so many stories like this go, she helps the family find each other (at least to some extent, as this family is extremely dysfunctional and just plain weird so they're never going to be close and happy) and finds herself. In time, she learns the art of the new science called photography (as she is the only one in the world who can come up with a formula to make the photographic chemical process work even tho top scientists have been trying to find the solution for years), and then when she returns home, she opens her own portrait studio with money from ?? some source.
If you can overlook some major flaws (if her family has so much wealth, fancy clothes, etc, then why leave home in order to earn a pittance as a governess; her employer never checks her references; if her Jewish roots and close-knit community are so close and so helpful, then why don't they help her, her mother and her sister after the father's death; how does she get the money to open the photo studio; how is it she solves the chemical process mystery when no one else can) and if dead critters don't make you bat an eye, then you might enjoy this period piece.
If you're a big Tom Wilkinson fan (The Full Monty, Separate Lies, Rush Hour 1), then you'll especially enjoy one scene in which he's "asleep" starkers (nekked/full frontal) and shows the world he has absolutely nothing to be ashamed of ;-)
Jonathan Rhys Meyers (Bend It Like Beckham) shows far more skin that Minnie Driver, showing his bare butt. His performance seems convoluted and overdone at best, and I think the film would've been better off without the character in the story. IMHO.
The employer's wife, although over-starched and with a voice that sounds worse than fingernails going down a chalkboard, is at least fairly essential to the story. But the character of the wife is very, very annoying.
If not for Tom Wilkinson, I'd give this film zero stars. But he always brings a certain something to a picture. Yes, even if he keeps his clothes on!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Loved it!, April 16 2004
This review is from: The Governess (DVD)
Sensual, sensuous, beautifully filmed, some nudity (which was delightful, although no sex, unfortunately), and a wonderful story of a woman's first love and love affair and blossoming into her power. The soundtrack was stunning. I recommend it highly!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
lotta plot(s), but lovely picture(s), Dec 5 2003
This review is from: The Governess (DVD)
The plots: sexual tension between a governess and her employer, tension of a woman in a foreign place, and all along the struggle to make pictures....
Mary, to the world, is a governess working in a Protestant house in Scotland. But Jane Eyre she isn't-she puts away her dreams of acting after the death of her father forces her to bring in a family income-all in the while she conceals that she is Rosina, a Jewess pretending to be of Italian descent. It is no lie when she reassures the lady of the house she isn't Catholic.
Her new surroundings are more than dyfunctional. The character of the bored mother is unoccupied and perched in a gilded but bland cage, propped up and seated in nearly every scene like she's dead and posed "in state." Her husband, Cavendish, hides away with his mysterious science studies and the daughter(Rosina/"Mary's" charge) whose responds to boredom (and a lack of attention) differently than her mother by playing pranks on her new governess. The son, a decade older and recently expelled from school, is a product of this same boredom, grown but immature as his sister and decidedly perverse.
After a prank by the daughter, the governess quickly lets her student know who's boss, and the student becomes more submissive. But their bonding lessens as Rosina's becomes curious about the father, who becomes equally curious about her. She pays less attention to her student and more to her employer, who, impressed with her knowledge and curiosty (he has no anger after she sneaks into his archaic photo laboratory) she eventually becomes his assistant. All in the while Rosina's dead father visits her in her dreams and memories-until Cavendish replaces her father in dreams and the two have an inevitable affair.
Then there is second plot is Rosina, a Jew of Spanish/Portuguese decent, who feels akward in a gentile setting. She isn't used to the foreign food (she and her sister once believed semolina to be semen) and artifacts. While it's funny to watch her pick up a crucifix for the first time, look at it, then toss it to the side, it's sad to watch her eat passover alone, in secret. She remembers her father and passover as a child as she eats an egg in salt water-which spills on a nearby photo. This is the breakthrough to getting a picture developed, literally, the third plot, Rosina and Cavendish learning the process of photogaphy,outside the sexual tension.
Though both are student to discovering the scientific process, it is only Rosina who is willing to take it a step further, photography as an art. The art/science photography is the undoing of their little situation, the business and pleasure. The final straw is Cavendish revealing his new process and not sharing the credit for it-he was still bitter about her secret pictures of him, nude, as he forbade.
So, Rosina, endowed with a new ability to make an income, decides it's unnecessary to hide her true identity or stay in the employ of a man who betrayed her. She leaves the family in style: on the way out the door she hands bored Mrs. Cavendish what the housewife always sat yearning for, a piece of "culture"-her husband's nude portrait.
That's just a few plot circles and it does feel like a long film at times. Rosina and Cavendish have a strange sexual tension, an attraction to each other (if not a lack of screen chemistry) that both characters seem almost surpised at. The younger Cavendish is an imp, hardly in the film (it's like he's purpose is to barely pop out from the background), and I wish he and Rosina had more screen time. Overall, it's a gorgous period film and the colorful setting of the Sephardic Jewish London is so welcome after a string of movies set in what feels like the same 19th century, Pre-Dickinson-Pre-Industrial rural 'scape. The Austin/Eliot/Brontes have their merits, and I am a fan of Sense and Sensibilty (Emma Thompson's), but I think Hollywood should keep taking us to new places, like in this lovely film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No