Most helpful customer reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
Riddles Wrapped into a Mystery Springing from a Tragedy, Jun 1 2003
This review is from: Grave Maurice (Hardcover)
This novel reminded me of one of those Russian nesting dolls, where you keep finding another doll inside of the one you are holding, when you take the doll apart. There's enough plot and character development here for 6 novels. I graded the book down mostly because no one should read this novel without having read quite a few of the earlier ones in the series. Most of the best references and ironies won't mean much otherwise. And many of them are rather long sections. Even in a series, authors need to make novels as stand-alone as they can. I also graded the book down because one plot element just didn't make sense to me (the location of the missing heroine for two years). On the other hand, I thought that the development of the theme of honoring animal rights was well done. I don't remember a novel that does it any better. Along the way, I had a lot of fun. Regular Richard Jury and Martha Grimes fans should definitely read this one! The Grave Maurice is one of Melrose Plant's best and most humorous outings. You see new sides of Richard Jury, and they will make him more appealing to you. I also appreciated the reference to Josephine Tey's wonderful book about Richard III. The Grave Maurice is also as steeped in English horse racing as the typical Dick Francis effort, which made the book all the more appealing to me. After you finish this story, think about the moral priorities for you in protecting life and liberty! What comes first?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Farfetched coincidences, don't you think?, Nov 29 2003
Warning! Gives away plot! A young girl is kidnapped and raped and they let her have the run of the farm? She has the run of the farm and she doesn't run away immediately? I can barely accept Maurice believing that his dead(!) father needs to speak to Nell (why?) but after realizing Nell is kidnapped, why would he keep silent? He knows who talked to him! Jockeys on the wrong horse? His wife jumps at the chance to identify someone else as her dead husband? No one misses the real dead guy? And then it's a case of revenge from a character we barely know? Oh, dear, this one really strains the imagination. And after all that, Nell dies? The only thing that might have saved this book for me is if Nell ended up with Vernon. I love Martha Grimes and I have been happily wending my way through the Richard Jury novels, but this one I wish I had missed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
A good book? Neigh..., Mar 7 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Grave Maurice (Hardcover)
In one of Martha Grimes's most recent books, a mystery writer complains about how she's become shackled to her fictional detective series to the degree that she'd be laughed at if she wrote "serious" fiction. Well, if Grimes herself is having the same kind of identity crisis, and this is the kind of "serious" fiction for which she wants to be known, then I'd rather she stop writing altogether. It won't be that great a stretch, as "The Grave Maurice" is hardly "writing" at all. It's some plotting, some character description and a lot of pontificating -- but it's not much of a book. I would say it's not up to Grimes's usual standards, but unfortunately, as her usual standards have plummeted in the past few years, this is sadly par for the course. So many of the once great mystery series out there (this one, Sue Grafton's Alphabet Series, Janet Evanovich's once-hilarious Stephanie Plum novels, most particulary Patricia Cornwell's Scarpetta books -- even the great P.D.James's latest) have taken on a stale, musty been-there-done-that, send-me-the royalty-checks quality. Writers do nothing more than insult the intelligence of loyal fans when they churn out chewed-over, by-the-numbers tripe. If you have nothing to say, ladies, don't say it. (And that goes for James Patterson and any number of male mystery authors who could never put two words together in the first place.) My apologies, folks, for the over-hyphenated (there I go again!) diatribe. I guess I'm just madder about wasting my time than I'd thought.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|