Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, Jan 31 2009
This review is from: Gravity (Paperback)
This book by Canadian first-time author Leanne Lieberman centers on the coming-of-age of Ellie Gold.
The story begins during the summer vacation: Ellie goes to her grandmother's cottage in the midst of immaculate natural beauty, a place that she has looked forward to returning to since her first visit. This trip ends unexpectedly, as Ellie ends up falling in love with a girl her age, realizing her homosexuality.
However, Ellie has been brought up with strict religious values and traditions, which do not accept homosexuality, and she is forced to choose between shunning her community or denying her true sexuality.
Ultimately, through the multiple conflicts illustrated between tradition and modernity, Lieberman establishes that there is a place for all types of people, including Ellie, in society and religion.
I definitely enjoyed this story. Lieberman sucessfully develops her characters, and does not shy away from the lust commonly experienced by teenagers. And, coupled with the homosexual storyline, this story provides for a very interesting read, and is friendly to those who are not familiar with Judaism, specifically Orthodoxy.
GRAVITY is a good read for any, and despite my initial questions of how Lieberman would create such a challenging story, my concerns were for naught, as the story is an excellent work.
Reviewed by: Andrew S. Cohen
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, Jan 31 2009
By TeensReadToo "Eat. Drink. Read. Be Merrier." - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Gravity (Paperback)
This book by Canadian first-time author Leanne Lieberman centers on the coming-of-age of Ellie Gold.
The story begins during the summer vacation: Ellie goes to her grandmother's cottage in the midst of immaculate natural beauty, a place that she has looked forward to returning to since her first visit. This trip ends unexpectedly, as Ellie ends up falling in love with a girl her age, realizing her homosexuality.
However, Ellie has been brought up with strict religious values and traditions, which do not accept homosexuality, and she is forced to choose between shunning her community or denying her true sexuality.
Ultimately, through the multiple conflicts illustrated between tradition and modernity, Lieberman establishes that there is a place for all types of people, including Ellie, in society and religion.
I definitely enjoyed this story. Lieberman sucessfully develops her characters, and does not shy away from the lust commonly experienced by teenagers. And, coupled with the homosexual storyline, this story provides for a very interesting read, and is friendly to those who are not familiar with Judaism, specifically Orthodoxy.
GRAVITY is a good read for any, and despite my initial questions of how Lieberman would create such a challenging story, my concerns were for naught, as the story is an excellent work.
Reviewed by: Andrew S. Cohen
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thoughtful Coming of Age Novel About a Jewish Teen Grappling with Her Sexuality, Nov 6 2009
By Rachel Kramer Bussel "Cupcakes Take the Cake ... - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Gravity (Paperback)
I came across Gravity randomly at my local library and was immediately intrigued. Lieberman places Ellie in her Orthodox Jewish Toronto home, with an older sister impatient to rid herself of the trappings of her religion, a mother going through a spiritual crisis, a father trying to keep a hold on his family and a grandmother who is devil-may-care with her brightly polished nails and disdain for the rigors of Orthodoxy. Ellie spends a summer with her grandmother while the rest of the family is in Israel, and it's there that she discovers, for real, that she is attracted to girls. Namely, Lindsay, a siren whose mom isn't around that much, who tells Ellie that she wants to be a stripper when she grows up.
It's clear to the reader that Lindsay is, in many ways, using Ellie--to feel loved and wanted, to up her experience, but she also has some genuine feelings for Ellie. Unfortunately, they are not as strong as Ellie's, and Ellie is also grappling with her growing concern that the religion she loves may not welcome her. Her efforts to find out what Orthodox Judaism thinks about gay people, and especially lesbians, are rendered extremely well by Lieberman. Ellie feels like she has no one to turn to, though her sister, knowing her so well susses out her secret.
This is a book about both coming out, or rather, coming to terms with one's sexual orientation, and trying to find a role for your newly different self within a familiar, and sometimes close-minded, environment. Ellie has to learn that she has the power to make her own decisions and choices and that there isn't always some authority to tell her what the right thing to do is. This is a moving, thoughtful look at a teen's sexual coming of age as well as religious thought process.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Gravity: The Incredible Attraction of a Stellar Novel, May 12 2009
By Kingham's Kids "Ms, Kingham's 7th Grade" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Gravity (Paperback)
Gravity, Leanne Lieberman's masterful and remarkable debut novel, tells one of the most profound and powerful tales of coming-of-age and exploring and understanding one's self that I have read. Leanne Lieberman conquers the heavily trodden path of teen self-discovery and sexual orientation and manages to interpret in an unprecedented and creative fashion. Ellie Gold, an orthodox Jew, has never doubted or resented her beliefs, but now, over the summer of her 15th year, she struggles to define and understand herself within the rigid lines of her religion. She encounters wild and liberal Lindsay, whose abandon and flamboyant nature provoke feelings and stirrings that challenge Ellie's perception of her self and cause the great difficulty of dealing with her emerging homosexuality. Ellie is lost, guilty, and unsure about to approach now a religion that tells her that her sexuality is a mistake or childish tendency, even a sin is followed. Ellie must choose between abandoning her perception of God and her beliefs of what is truly right and wrong, or bury and hide the feelings and personality that she cannot deny. The realistic fiction genre is not one of my favorites; however, I felt that Gravity was exceptional. Ellie's attempt to judge and really comprehend her religion is one that I can understand. If God loves everyone, why does he disown the homosexuals or those who don't keep Sabbath or follow strict religious practices?
I thoroughly enjoyed Gravity and hope that all teens, going through a time of self definition, as well as those who are coming out, or confronting a part of themselves that have not, will also. Ellie, Lindsay, and Ellie's diverse and rich family are all highly developed and deep characters, each with their own quirks, yet able to maintain personalities that one can relate to or connect to people in our own lives. Their deep nature adds to the already extensively original and unique plot, concluding in a surprising yet wrenchingly realistic ending. Although the Gravity was admittedly not written very complicatedly, the blatant honesty of Ellie and her childish innocence reversed any detraction from the text. I would encourage people of all ages and religions to begin the splendid journey and mental trek that one will certainly experience upon ordering Gravity. ~~ C.S.H.
|
|
|