3.0 out of 5 stars
Every recipe needs to be tested first, Sep 1 2010
This review is from: Great Curries of India (Hardcover)
I strongly suspect most reviewers here have read this book rather than cooked from it.
Once you've deciphered what she's talking about and tested out her recipes you can produce excellent dishes. They usually involve lots of work, but that's Indian cooking. The big issue, only mentioned by one other reviewer, is that Panjabi's recipes are chock full of errors. Ingredients listed in the heading never appear in the description, and vice versa. Quantities are all over the place, sometimes wildly inaccurate. You definitely do not want to invite guests over for a meal from this book without going through a dry-run for the family first.
Just one of countless examples, the chick-pea dish near the end:
1)Calls for 1/3 cup, 9 oz of dried chick peas. 1/3 of a cup is about 2 oz, 9 oz is about one cup. Which is it? Neither?
2)Calls for 3 onions. Then in the body of the recipe you're asked to chop 2, puree one, and add the ........... wait a minute, 4th? to the peas you've put in the pressure cooker.
3)Calls for 1/2 oz ginger, peeled, 1/2 oz garlic. 1/2 oz of ginger is hardly worth bothering with after you've peeled it and 1/2 oz garlic is about 5 cloves, pretty overpowering in a veggie dish. I suspect yet another typo. Or two.
And so it goes on. The introductory pages, intended to give you an overview of Indian ingredients, is big on nice pictures and by-the-way stuff, low on what you need to know from a cooking and preparation standpoint.
I've used the book for years, enjoyed many dishes from it, but only after a laborious vetting process that often ends with me tossing it to the back of the shelf on being caught out by yet another error. In fairness, it's a problem that afflicts every Indian cooking book I've ever used. As my son, who travelled the country for a year, says, that's the joy and frustration of India.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent presentation.., Dec 18 2003
This review is from: Great Curries of India (Hardcover)
I collect Indian cookbooks and this is one of the jewels of my collection. Camellia brings a delicious flair to the recipes in her presentation. Well chosen curries and fairly good ingredient measurements allow novices to fare well, But If you're from an Indian origin or well-versed in the tastes of the curries, You'd do well to experiment with the ingredient measurements.( Some dishes are made all over India with the same curry base, but varying amount of ingredients and regional produce give the dishes different flavours.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
powerful cookbook!, Nov 21 2002
This review is from: Great Curries of India (Hardcover)
this book has all the main superpowers: beauty, variety, indexing, cultural notes, explanation of ingredients, accessibility of ingredients, deliciousness, serving suggestions, flexibility, practical hints. including a recipe for watermelon curry is regarded as an additional special power.
my only complaint, which hasn't ever ruined a meal, is that many key ingredient amounts are given by weight. i am not a person who considers potatoes or tomatoes in ounces.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No