3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Executioner, Sep 1 2010
By C. R. Dillon - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Great Ideas The Executioner (Paperback)
First, the Penguin Great Ideas run-down: These editions have no notes, no context, no biography or introduction. You just get text.
This particular volume contains the first, part of the second, and the seventh dialogue from "Les Soirées de Saint-Pétersbourg". The dialogues begin with the old question why bad things happen to good people and why bad people often prosper.
The whole thing suffers somewhat by the argument about Providence and a "well, because that's how God planned it" element which doesn't make it very original or fun to read. The work meanders a bit like a real dialogue. Yet the best parts drop that and are obviously literary.
In two or three places it gets quite good, with wonderful passages about humanity's need for war, and unsurprisingly, the life and role of an executioner. If it weren't for these flights it would be a 2 star review; but they're so good it makes up for the lackluster rest of the work.