6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Waste of money, Sep 10 2010
By DP - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Ground Up (Paperback)
I am a food literature fan, but this book left me immensely disappointed. If you want a well-paced read with interesting, less than perfect characters try Bourdin's "Kitchen Confidential." The only reason I finished this book was because I spent my money on it and didn't want to waste it completely. If it was a library book, I probably would have returned it right around 2/3 through the book. In fact, I sold it to Half Priced Books the day I finished it, because it was that annoying.
What I disliked about this book:
-utter pretension at every turn, even in the literary references of the narrator, not just of the pretensions of the characters
-the unnecessary "gotcha" ending wherein the reader learns the entire relationship and previously described impetus of the cafe was actually a lie
-the characters: You will not find one likable character in the bunch; they are all annoying douchebags. I liked Shadow in "American Gods," Odysseus in Homer's "Odyssey"--hell, I even liked Anita Blake right up to around "Cerulean Sins" or "Incubus Dreams." I even sort of like bad guys and unsavory types in other works, but wow, just wow. Idov is successful in creating the most annoying, one-dimensional, self-righteous, entitled spoiled brat protagonists. Even the last few pages don't redeem them and don't reveal any major changes in their personalities. It was very disappointing.
The most shameful thing about this book is that it is being peddled as some great statement about the American Dream. Yet, this book in no way portrays the American Dream, because the protagonists aren't interested in surviving, thriving and growing through hard work, personal sacrifices, and truly working together to achieve financial success and ultimately achieving personal fulfillment. It's as though they move backwards beginning from a state of utter fulfillment toward misery after they try to superimpose their upper crust ways on anyone and everyone remotely associated with Cafe Kolschitsky.
This is just another hobby business run by superficial, self-righteous kids who are ashamed of their hard-working parents and disdainful--no, downright contemptuous of the levels of hard work and successes their parents achieved. They have no sense of guilt or shame about being so self-centered and unappreciative; they are hollow, superficial hipsters whose only concerns are being anti-everything except for satisfying their desires to feel superior to everyone else.
I get that this is satire, but these characters don't go through any kind of redemption. They are boring, annoying and, ultimately, wasted my time.
5 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The American Dream gone bad -- with humor!, Sep 6 2009
By J. Luiz - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Ground Up (Paperback)
For anyone who ever dreamed of how ideal it would be to run your own business -- a quaint bookstore or cute coffee shop -- this book should be read as a warning treatise waking you up out of your naive reverie. Idov has an expansive knowledge of food and language, which he uses with great effect here to offer of a portait who naively enter the business world, believing they can wow the residents of the Lower East Side of Manhattan with a thoroughly authentic Viennese-style coffeehouse. They quickly learn the realities of what they have to do to compete with the Starbucks-style competitors and the descent from the heights of their idealistic fantasies to the pits of their daily struggles to earn enought to even pay their rent makes for a very entertaining read. The main protagonist, his lawyer-trained wife, her domineering mother and the ex-Israeli landlord who controls the Lower East Side all make for terrfiic characters. If you enjoy the author's wonderful use of language, I can strongly recommend Robert Cohen's [Amateur Barbarians: A Novel, as I suspect you will enjoy Cohen's masterful prose style, as well.
4 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ground Up: A Praise, Sep 1 2009
By M Mealand - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Ground Up (Paperback)
A very fun and engaging book - read over a weekend. At a basic level, it is superbly written - great language, references to anything that can be referenced in a sentence. Humor is excellent, sharp, original and sufficiently self-depreciating; satire is equal-opportunity and leaves few characters untouched, yet doesn't go overboard. It is also much more than a story of one coffee shop's failure; rather, the plot line (with some great twists) is the canvas for a much broader picture. The author is on top of mostly everything that has been happening NYC recently, and the book contains a good snapshot of that, which New Yorkers are certain to recognize and appreciate, and everyone else should get to know, before it happens in a city near them. Read it - you are certain not to be bored.