3 Guys 1 Girl 2 Weddings

One gay roommate adores his best friend but the problem is that roomate is straight. Not only that, but the roommate is falling in love with a girl. Complications... A frothy, light comedy that is fun to watch. My favorite scene occurs where the best friend lends his bride's wedding dress so that his roommate can use it as a prop in a gay parade. When the bride sees "her dress" being ripped up on television...well...

Until the last 11 minutes I was delighted with this film. While it is certainly no masterpiece, the characters were delightful and charming, the writing and production quite good, etc. I was basking in my enjoyment and looking forward with joyful anticipation to a DVD to add to my list of top favorites.

Then came the awful last 11 minutes. Why awful? The writers suddenly do a complete and implausible U-turn, and after 77 minutes of delightful buildup to a certain and specific conclusion, they abruptly shift everything, ignoring all the buildup and foreshadowing which has been carefully laid throughout the film (some of it quite strong), and switch the couples around with very little (and in one case NO) character motivation.

One character which has been merely an associate of one of the main characters suddenly (and for no apparent reason) proposes marriage, throwing the whole careful buildup of the film right out the window.

Another major earlier plot twist (the stag night "tied to the bed" Lea scene) is left completely unresolved (I suspect that in the original script, the main character's finding out about the truth of this scene was the device which would have led to his making the proper choice, and giving us the clearly satisfying ending to the film).

This is the most disappointed I've been with a film in a long time, and the disappointment is made all the more bitter because the first 77 minutes of the film is so charming and delightful. The last 11 minutes throw it all away, and leaves the viewer with a tasteless and unsatisfying experience.

I'd suggest only buying this one if you are capable of switching it off as the first wedding begins (approx. 77 minutes in), and writing or mentally composing your own ending. To watch the one presented in the film is to taint the whole experience.

I would be willing to bet that there is a "story" behind this absurd and sudden turnabout in the script, such as a new producer or writer suddenly brought into the production team who insisted upon a more "mainstream ending". It certainly makes no sense in the film.

I am glad to note that one reviewer below has ammended his review to add a similar cautionary note to mine.

While viewing the first 77 minutes of the film I sat there increasingly enthralled and knowing increasingly for certain that this would become a treasured part of my collection. Now, after viewing the ending, I don't even wish to view the film again until I can write my own ending and put it in the DVD case with a cautionary note to stop the DVD at 77 minutes in and read my written ending instead.

So, I have to rate it as follows:

4 1/2 Stars -- (the first 77 minutes)

0 Stars -- (the last 11 minutes)

Thus averaging the two together one arrives at 2 stars, which I honestly feel I must round down to 1 due to the disappointment factor.

BOTTOM LINE: what should have been a completely delightful and charming film ends up being a very unsatisfying viewing experience.

If you want to view a French film with similar themes and which is very well done, buy JUST A QUESTION OF LOVE, which is available from our friends here at Amazon.

This is a one-joke/one-issue movie that isn't clever, nor does it cover any new ground, and the central charater is a whining irritating self-centered dullard who can't accept that someone he loves might not love him back. (It sure wasn't hard for me to imagine.)

The supporting characters are dull and lifeless, and one of them proposes to the central character. I had difficulty caring. I kept looking at the time to see whether it was almost finished.

I must say that if you're interested in this movie, please do yourself a favor and see "All Over The Guy." It's in ENGLISH, it's cute, funny, intelligent, manages to avoid scenes of public urination, and it's much more enjoyable and affecting that this clunker. "Just One Time" is also noteworthy, supporting the same basic story line as this movie, and is also far superior in every way.

I wouldn't say completely avoid this as a rental, but it's certainly not a "keeper" (or even close) for me.

› Go to Amazon.com to see all 7 reviews  3.4 out of 5 stars