11 of 11 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Grand New Edition of a Classic, Mar 7 2003
By TahoeKay "Kay" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Hardy Roses: A Practical Guide To Varieties And Techniques (Hardcover)
The solid cultural information, beautiful photographs, and evocative descriptions made Hardy Roses: An Organic Guide to Growing Frost-and Disease-Resistant Varieties (c. 1991) my favorite rose book.
Now this classic is available in a revised edition, now called Hardy Roses: A Practical Guide to Varieties and Techniques (2001). Though the sub-title has changed, the updated and expanded chapters on propagating and nurturing roses and dealing with insects and diseases remain solidly in the organic camp.
34 new roses have been added to the heart of the book which includes descriptions and photographs of roses which have done well in the author's Canadian nursery.
There are also two other features. There is an updated list of 200 varieties of hardy roses and also an appendix listing nurseries, rose organizations and source books (no Internet addresses, alas!)
This book complements Jerry Olson's Growing Roses in Cold Climates. I like having both.
Should a rose fancier who already has the first edition buy the second? There is nothing wrong with the first edition (it is less expensive and still available) but for me, I wanted those 34 new roses! I'm glad I went ahead with this purchase.
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Book for Cold Climate Rose Growers, Sep 13 2005
By Julie O - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Hardy Roses: A Practical Guide To Varieties And Techniques (Hardcover)
This is the quintessential book for rose growing in northern climates. The book offers excellent recommendations for selecting roses that are both winter hardy as well as disease tolerant for the coldest regions of the US. The first edition of "Hardy Roses" became my bible for rose selection thirteen years ago, and as a resident of Zone 3 northern Wisconsin I can vouch for the advice that it provides, both for rose selection as well as a healthy and common sense approach to rose care. The new edition expands the number of recommended varieties and is a book to reread frequently and keep forever. Don't loan it out or you may never see it again!