From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5-Harold, a squirrel, lives in a New York City park, tours the area daily, and samples nuts offered by his human friends. Life is good until a rat suggests that it is only Harold's bushy tail that separates him from the lowly and loathed rat world. To test this hypothesis, Harold agrees to having his tail shaved. The rodents break into a barbershop, the rat glues Harold's tail fur onto his own spindly tail, and the two trade places. Sure enough, Harold is treated cruelly by his former benefactors and chased out of a nearby park by haughty squirrels. He finally finds shelter in a cellar with other outcast but friendly rats. By the story's conclusion, the counterfeit squirrel gets his comeuppance, Harold's fur has grown back, and he's made new friends. Frequent black-and-white line drawings move the tale along. Children may have a difficult time getting by the believability factor and caring about Harold and his predicament. George Selden's Cricket in Times Square (Farrar, 1960) tells a better friendship story and E. B. White's Stuart Little (HarperCollins, 1945) is a more compelling adventure.
Susan Hepler, Burgundy Farm Country Day School, Alexandria, VACopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Gr. 3-6. Gone are Harold the Squirrel's cushy, nut-feasting days in Manhattan Island (a real park on Manhattan's west side) after a conniving rat talks him into shaving the fur off his tail. Now, because he looks like a common rat, he's forced to hit the streets, where he hooks up with an unusual trio of rats, learns how to sleep during the day, scavenge for food at night, and escape unleashed dogs. Harold also discovers that the only difference between food and garbage is a matter of opinion. Told in first-person, often in a rather adult-sounding voice, this clever, urban animal survival tale is New York-centric in a fun way: the places are real and the observations ("New Yorkers are always late to parties and never pay attention") ring true. Black-and-white drawings add zest to the entertaining satire about humans in fur, which has read-aloud potential.
Julie CumminsCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved