15 of 15 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A five star dictionary alone--but not as an upgrade, Mar 14 2006
By Kevin Arthur Wong "pheriwinkle" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: HarperCollins Robert French Unabridged Dictionary (Hardcover)
I think this is the best single-volume, bilingual dictionary available for French and English. However, one word of warning, if you already own the sixth edition of this work, do not think you're getting much in purchasing the seventh. Every section has an identical number of pages. Really, the only updates you're getting (other than corrections) are a few words inserted here and there--not enough to change the total page count of any particular section. For instance, I found the new terms "weblog" and "webmail" (although "blog" was not included) in comparing one page between the sixth and seventh editions. So if you already own the sixth edition, realize that you will get very little more in upgrading to the seventh. For this reason, I'm thinking of returning it. One nice change, however, is that the seventh edition does not have the fairly useless thumb index and has a plain edge.
That being said, in comparison with the Larousse and Harrap's single-volume, bilingual dictionaries, I definitely think this one is the richest in terms of defining real usage. I keep Larousse as a backup and have dispensed with my Harrap's all together.
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent work, Jan 29 2006
By Felicien - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: HarperCollins Robert French Unabridged Dictionary (Hardcover)
While it is certainly impossible for a dictionary to be completely up-to-date and 100% comprehensive, this dictionary is very close. It is a great primary dictionary and can almost stand alone without a backup dictionary. No translator should be without it. And the price is phenomenal for the value.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not the Last French Dictionnary You'll Ever Buy, July 16 2006
By William Shriver - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: HarperCollins Robert French Unabridged Dictionary (Hardcover)
Although I cannot begrudge this fine dictionary that fifth star, it doesn't come close to reaching the bar set by the word "unabridged" when applied to English dictionaries. As others have noted, this is ideal as a dictionary of first resort. That said, for a dictionary whose cover boasts "Thousands of...Technical...Terms," I still find myself returning to my HARRAP'S NEW COLLEGIATE for such things as botanical names, culinary terms, and the like. What's more, the tiny LAROUSSE DE POCHE is still a much better authority on the French/English cognates. Still, the ROBERT will almost supplant those half-dozen books of French slang you have beaten to death, and it is unparalleled in its organization. You can't beat the price, and if you spend any time reading in French or listening to French, it is easily the best bargain out there. Just don't throw away your other dictionaries.