5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best Box Set of 1970's, Period!, April 1 2012
This review is from: Have a Nice Decade Box (Audio CD)
I haven't found a better collection of 1970's songs than this. The 7 CD's are full of music, with 20-24 songs on each, plus several brief news clips (which don't cut of the songs) which are fun to hear, a fantastic booklet (with a shag rug cover), and well designed package to hold it all.
These are the original hits by the original artists (except Styx' "Lady" is not the hit version for some reason). This collection represents 1970's a.m. radio, which often played shorter (i.e. 45 rpm) versions of songs, so long album tracks were edited down for radio... that's the way they were heard on radio and how they're heard here. All of these songs WERE huge hits, and it was good to hear them again, although not all have aged equally well. 1970's a.m. radio played quite an eclectic mixture of music and this CD set captures that well. I'd say most 1970 pop music is represented well here, except for punk and hard rock... but those were heard more on f.m. radio anyways.
I should say that I bought this collection when it first came out and paid about $140 for it. Since there are 160 songs, that's less than $1 per song. The price for the set has since increased a lot, but I still think it offers much value.
Rhino also has a 25 CD set of 1970's music, with 12 songs per CD making it a more extensive set; however those CD's were sold separately and the overall price was significantly more. You can sometimes find some of those individual CD's in cheapie bins. This 7 CD set is a condensed version of the bigger set, and I think it is a better value.
The main competition is the Sounds of the Seventies CD's put out by Time-Life. It's a good collection but I have some issues with it:
1) The Time-Life series seems to have remixed the songs, often changing the stereo imagery and original EQ's of the songs. I compared them to records I had of some of the songs and the mixes were indeed changed. I much prefer the sound of the Rhino CD's.
2)The Time-Life CD's were usually sold individually (I'm not sure if they ever sold the entire set together) and a HUGE PROBLEM for me, a Canadian, is that the American versions of the same CD's contained twice as many songs for the same price; the Canadian versions of the CD's only had about 10 songs on each, so many of the songs that were advertised and available to Americans were not available to Canadians.
3)The bulk of songs on the Time-Life collection were by artists who I already had greatest hits CD's of; the Rhino set gave me more of the one-hit wonder songs I needed. I think the entire Time-Life set contained only 20 songs MAXIMUM that were not on this Rhino 7-CD set or on hits CD's I already owned, again making the Rhino set a better value for me. For someone who does not already own CD's by Fleetwood Mac, Foreigner, Paul McCartney & Wings, Eagles, Bee Gees, etc. may prefer the song selection on the Time-Life set.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
A great way to revisit to joys of '70s AM radio, May 22 2004
This review is from: Have a Nice Decade Box (Audio CD)
Perhaps my favorite box set. This reminds me so much of listening to KYA or KFRC (two top-40 stations in San Francisco in the 1970's), when you would here rock, then country, then pop, then novelty songs. A fantastic blend. Favorite songs include: Popcorn, Chick-A-Boom(hadn't heard this since the '70s), Love Goes, More More More, Love Rollercoaster, School's Out, Dueling Banjos, Candy Man, Rose Garden, and I could go on. One star is missing due to
a. Some songs are cut
b. Some songs I would have liked to see(licensing would have been an issue on some) include
My Sharona by The Knack(biggest hit of 1979)
Stayin' Alive by the Bee Gees
Bennie & the Jets by Elton John
Escape(The Pina Colada Song) by Rupert Holmes
I Think I Love You by The Partridge Family
Gonna Fly Now(Theme From Rocky)
Silly Love Songs by Paul McCartney and Wings
Beth by Kiss
If You Leave Me Now by Chicago
Dancing Queen by Abba
We've Only Just Begun by The Carpenters
(Take Me Home) Country Roads by John Denver
Nadia's Theme
All of the above were major top 10 hits(most were big number #1s)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Right Down To The Puke Green Carpet, Oct 11 2003
This review is from: Have a Nice Decade Box (Audio CD)
Being born in 1970,and growing up around alot of this music,HAND had to be in my music collection.
Hearing these songs bring back memories good(The Candy Man)& bad(Disco Duck,Convoy)as well as introducing me to long forgotten tunes(Chevy Van,Alone Again<naturally>)as well as those that should've remain forgotten(Afternoon Delight).
But like all era compilations not everything could fit or be licensed(Springsteen,Elton,solo Beatles).So for every song I wanted on HAND(Tighter,Tighter,Loving You)there are those I'm glad wasn't included(Playground on my Mind)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No