28 of 29 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
The most disappointing Catherine Anderson book I've ever read..., Jan 31 2011
By kiki - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Here to Stay: A Harrigan Family Novel (Mass Market Paperback)
Catherine Anderson has been on my "Automatically Buy" list since I read my first book by her(It was "My Sunshine"). I couldn't wait to get my hands on Here To Stay, and I went and bought it the day it came out. I wish I hadn't. This is by far the worst book I've ever read by Catherine Anderson. 100 pages into the book, the hero and heroine had only had about 2 or 3 scenes together. Mandy was one of the most annoying heroines I have ever encountered. I love strong heroines who are quiet and laid back, but Mandy was simply a doormat. Catherine Anderson is notorious for her tortured heroines, but because we were never able to really see into Mandy, its VERY hard to sympathize with her. There's just something... missing from the story. The magic that makes Catherine Anderson a master at what she does is missing. I would not recommend this book. It was so boring, I couldn't even finish it. If you have to read it, pick it up from the library or buy it at a used book sale.
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
A page-turner from a talented author, Jan 29 2011
By Pamela B. Hermano "Kookykrumbs" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Here to Stay: A Harrigan Family Novel (Mass Market Paperback)
I wouldn't categorize this book with Catherine Anderson's best. However, it kept me interested and I finished it in just two sittings. I can't say that about a lot of the books coming out these days. My only criticism is that although overall it is a sweet love story, the animals in the story took too much of the attention away from the actual main characters. The good thing though was that the presence of the animals at least helped progress the story further. The author is definitely an animal lover and it shows in all of her books, but unfortunately she just didn't get the right balance in this book. I was looking for something more along the lines of her earlier works like Baby Love, Phantom Waltz, My Sunshine (Coulter Family) and Seventh Heaven. In those books, animals were still present in the overall plot, but not overwhelmingly. I mean, at the halfway point of Here To Stay, I knew more about the animals than I did either of the main characters. I cared more for Rosebud and Tornado as well as the heroine's brother, Luke than I did the two (supposedly) main characters. But don't get me wrong, overall I still recommend the book, and Catherine Anderson is still on my autobuy list of authors, I guess her Harrigan series just isn't impressing me as much as her Coulter/Keegan series.
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
I think all of us will be wanting a Rosebud of our own, Jan 31 2011
By broiderqueen "army mama" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Here to Stay: A Harrigan Family Novel (Mass Market Paperback)
Catherine Anderson is one of my favorite contemporary authors. She is one of the few authors whose books I buy as soon as they are published - all of them. Some are better than others, though, and "Here to Stay", while being very good, wasn't at the top of my list of favorites. Don't get me wrong - it was certainly well worth reading but I found myself comparing it to some of her earlier works that really knocked my socks off, such as My Sunshine, Blue Skies, or Phantom Waltz. Anderson incorporates characters with physical disabilities into a lot of her books and does it well, allowing them full, healthy lives DESPITE any handicaps they might have.
Luke in "Here to Stay" was blinded in an accident when very young and is not a very sympathetic character for a good portion of the book. His sister, Mandy, who is his caretaker is also a huge enabler. So there are parts of the book where I just wanted to slap one or the other of them.
I enjoyed the character of Zach, the rancher who is now raising mini guide horses and especially fell in love with Rosebud, the little horse-in-training. There were some scenes that stretched my sense of belief (I am not sure how credible it actually would be to have these mini horses doing guide work, especially in an urban setting; or the scenes with the "killer" stallion turned into a teddybear - maybe I just don't know enough to be well informed) but this is fiction and I enjoyed the book and would recommend it to romance readers or those who love animals.