Hope and Despair in the American City: Why There Are No Bad Schools in Raleigh Hardcover – May 30 2009
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
In Hope and Despair in the American City, Gerald Grant has written a profound book about American cities and their schools. He combines far-ranging scholarship with lively field research, autobiography, historical narrative, and an expert grasp of demographic data and the winding mazes of legal opinion. The result is a big and ambitious portrait, through the story of two cities, of our nation's greatest educational problems and possibilities for school reform in the metropolitan U.S. today.
--Joseph Featherstone, Michigan State University
A penetrating account of two cities and their school systems, one in the Northeast where decline and demographic change have brought difficult problems, and another in the growing South which has turned its socioeconomic challenges into opportunities. Anyone interested in educational reform will have to take account of this valuable analysis of the variable fates of our cities, and their schools.
--Nathan Glazer, Harvard University
The book is a must-read for anyone interested in urban planning, race relations and education reform. (Publishers Weekly (starred review) 2009-03-16)
Gerald Grant, a professor of education and sociology at Syracuse University, has written a compelling new book...He compares the troubled school system of Syracuse, N.Y., with its thriving similarly sized counterpart in Raleigh, N.C. The difference is that in Raleigh, in 1976, the Wake County Public School system was created to zone the suburbs and inner city together to ensure a continued healthy mix of social classes.
--Sandra Tsing Loh (New York Times on the Web 2009-04-28)
The book has the mark of a historian's well-documented journey.
--Tim Simmons (News & Observer 2009-05-17)
Essential reading not only for his target audience of education reformers but for anyone concerned with the fate of smaller cities...Though few know it, we now live with a grand historical irony: Public schools in the South are far more integrated than most in the North, whose cities, especially the "forgotten" ones, have become ever more doughnutlike. When we consider the failures of busing, we think of the awful mid-'70s wars in Boston...Grant's fine book shows there's another way, one keyed to restoring the educational center of metropolitan-wide economic development, if only we can summon the political will to do it.
--Catherine Tumber (Bookforum 2009-06-01)
The author blends his personal experiences with wide-ranging interviews and a dash of research to provide a largely sound analysis of the state of urban education.
--Phil Brand (Washington Times 2009-05-29)
Hope and Despair in the American City is a rare policy book: brief, personal, and flat-out persuasive. Comparing the catastrophically bad school system in Syracuse, where he lives, with the astonishingly successful one in the North Carolina capital, the author quickly alights on a convincing explanation for the disparity.
--Daniel Okrent (Fortune 2009-06-08)
In this perceptive and important new book, Gerald Grant tells a modern tale of two cities--Syracuse, New York, and Raleigh, North Carolina--that took starkly different approaches to improving schools and communities...What is astounding--and profoundly disturbing--is that education reform at the national level has basically ignored the type of findings so powerfully outlined in Hope and Despair in the American City.
--Richard D. Kahlenberg (Washington Monthly 2009-09-01)
Something extraordinary has been happening in the [North Carolina's] schools over the past few decades, and the best guide to this experiment is an important new book by Gerald Grant...He found that the single biggest factor determining whether you do well at school or not isn't your parents, your teachers, your school buildings or your genes. It was, overwhelmingly, the other kids sitting in the classroom with you...If a critical mass of them are hard-working, keen and stick to the rules, you will probably learn...Within a decade, Raleigh went from one of the worst-performing districts in America to one of the best.
--Johann Hari (The Independent 2009-10-16)
Gerald Grant's short book tells [its] story very well. It is that rarity among policy tomes: a page-turner. The political calculation that Richard Nixon made in 1971, when he nominated William Rehnquist to the Supreme Court, was borne of his desire to keep Southern and suburban white voters out of the hands of George Wallace and his populist racial appeal--and it saddled America with a Supreme Court whose decisions in the 1970s, specifically on school desegregation, proved evil...Grant points out over and over again that the true achievement of Raleigh and of the other metro-school metros is much more about integrating the social classes than it is about race.
--Bruce Fisher (Hartford Courant 2010-02-28)
About the Author
Gerald Grant is the Hannah Hammond Professor of Education and Sociology, Emeritus at Syracuse University.
Inside This Book(Learn More)
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
The author has managed to make the book an interesting read by weaving in details of his own family's life in Syracuse. Because I live in Raleigh/Wake County, I found the section on Raleigh's long history (dating back to the Civil War) of progressive racial integration policies fascinating, and it helped me put into proper perspective the "battle" that is currently being waged between those who support our school system's diversity policy, and those who do not.
This book is enlightening and well-written. If you have any interest in learning more about how our society can begin to tackle the problem of poverty, you will enjoy reading this book!
How did Syracuse and so many other northern cities reach this state of educational (and urban) decay? In contrast, Raleigh, NC has for decades been economically thriving and, most relevantly, successful with its schools, which have high achievement and graduation rates for black as well as white students, for poor as well as middle-class students. Is Raleigh's success a simple consequence of its economic growth? Apparently not since other southern cities with similar growth have not had the same educational success. Professor Grant shows convincingly that much of Raleigh's success stemmed from its willingness to integrate its schools over the entire metropolitan area, city and suburbs.
Sociologists of education know well that changing the culture of a school, from ghetto to middle class, is the most important element in school success, in teacher satisfaction, and in producing successful graduates. And the best way to do that is to mix minority students into a predominately middle-class student body. Since urban residence patterns remain segregated by race and economics, this necessarily means busing, a solution some reviewers of this book find unappealing. No doubt there are costs to school integration, but Grant's comparison of Raleigh to Syracuse shows that the benefits are substantial.
1.The theory of the doughnut hole. Once thriving cities like Syracuse, Rochester and Buffalo have had their wealth and populations redistributed to the outskirts, leaving low-income residents that do nothing to maintain or contribute to the cities. Am I generally speaking? Yes, but I also believe the fault falls partially to the cities who cannot seem to organize enough efforts to train the left over population, and drive out the cancers that seem to fill it. Grant claims that socio-economically balanced schools would, and have, cured such cancers.
2.Socio-economically balanced schools vs. racially balanced schools. This just makes sense. From having grown up in a low-income neighborhood, and school district, I know that it was not the color of the skin that held some students back.
Overall, it was a short book with a great comparison worth reading about. I enjoyed it also because it hit close to home.
Look for similar items by category
- Books > Education & Reference > Schools & Teaching > Education Theory
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Politics
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Political Science > Levels of Government
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Sociology > Rural
- Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Sociology > Urban