2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Super-Hero Saga Since Crisis On Infinite Earths, April 30 2008
DC Comics' Identity Crisis has been acclaimed by critics and fans. The rationale for its success can be attributed to the following main reasons;
1) an engrossing plot line that is skilfully written
2) beautiful art work
3) a gripping story that has impact on the characters
This is why Identity Crisis will also be considered a standard twenty years from now.
The pacing is over-the-top while the passion of the characters is felt with emotions running high in their search for the culprit(s). Meltzer makes us care about Elongated Man's pain, Robin's intense reaction to his inability in rescuing the most important person of his life as well as The Atom's poignant reaction towards the murderer.
While the script contains strong elements, it is Meltzer's ability to manipulate the reader with the heroes and villains' characterization that makes him capture our imagination. After battering our senses with death and tragedy, Meltzer hits it out of the ballpark with the final act. Life and the human sprit endure for our heroes despite the loss of their loved ones. They all come to terms with it in their own time and manner with the aftermath of the situation. The interaction between Superman and his mother, Nightwing attempting to reach out to Robin in his hour of need or Elongated Man coping with his grief gives the story the proper closure that makes this series an instant classic.
A powerful script does not make a great comic. There....
....I said it and am glad that I did because it is the truth point blank. Many argue that visual is not important or secondary to which I have to wonder why they bother with comic books instead of a novel in the first place. While Meltzer's ability as a comic book writer is the revelation, it is Rags Morales' artwork for Identity Crisis that has now propelled him as one of the top tier pencillers of the industry. With inspired styling from the likes of Neal Adams and John Buscema, Morales has developed his own that breathes life and authenticity to the characters. Every range of the human expression is to be found here and his realistic rendering is as much to be credited for the series' success as Meltzer's writing.
The events that transpire within the story leaves a permanent mark in the DC Universe and have consequences for years to come. Identity Crisis is the best super-hero saga since the cancellation of James Robinson and Tony Harris' Starman. This is not about the fancy costumes or gimmicks but rather the brave men and women who wear them. Specifically, the possible dangers, consequences and regrets that await for committing themselves to be noble with their gifts.
Review by Brian Grindrod
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wow very impressed, Nov 2 2006
To preface my review I haven't quite finished reading it yet, I am on the last chapter. Anyway a friend and I routinely buy graphic novels and trade them back and forth to read. This was one of his, and I wish I had bought it!
Very basically this is a mystery murder graphic novel featuring the superheros from the DC universe. Someone is killing off their loved ones and the heros are desprete to find out who it is and stop them.
This has to be one of my favorite graphic novels of all time so far. Up there with Batman: Dark knight returns, and Kingdom come, and the Watchmen. You get a glimpse of the darker sides of superheros, and I found it to be an emotionally wrought read. Buy this one, I doubt you will be disappointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Edge of my seat ending, Dec 23 2011
I got this upon recomendation from a friend. As a non DC fan I didnt really know too much about the characters or vilians but I absolutly loved this book. I loved how it was written and the emotional rollercoaster it took me through. There is a "surprise" ending that completely rocked me. I highly recomend this to anyone!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No