Most helpful customer reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent for Jaded Readers, Mar 23 2004
This review is from: Island of Ghosts: A Novel of Roman Britain (Mass Market Paperback)
Yup. That's me - a jaded reader. I suppose I've just spent too many hours reading lousy books and that, combined with an extreme lack of time, has made me extremely choosy about the books that I choose to spend my time on these days. If you're like me you'll probably enjoy this offering from Gillian Bradshaw. Ariantes is the honorable commander of a group of semi-barbaric Sarmatians who have been beaten, and then recruited by, 2nd century AD Romans. Unlike the other army commanders he cares enough about his men to Romanize a bit if that's what it takes to keep them alive in their new posting - far-off Britain. I found this novel to be a pleasant romp through ages past - not too deep, and just suprising enough to be satisfying. Bradshaw does an admirable job of evoking Ariantes' barbaric mindset, even if he is a bit too self-sacrificing now and then. The main characters are nicely fleshed out, though the villain is a bit too one-dimensional for my tastes - but then it's a very rare book that can satisfy me in that regard. I'm a historian - not a historical nit-picker - and found this book to do a good job of representing the past. The plot wasn't complex enough to give me a headache, which I like. Plus, I rather enjoyed reading about someone who excelled in administration. Not the most glorious of occupations, for sure, but don't worry - there's enough fighting and action in here to mix things up if that's more to your taste.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Island of Ghosts, Jun 20 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Island of Ghosts: A Novel of Roman Britain (Mass Market Paperback)
After defeat by the Romans, the Sarmatian cavalryman Ariantes must adjust to life as a commander in Roman service in Britain. I thought this was good, solid, historical fiction. The bits of Sarmatian culture and tactics, reconstructed believably by the author from the few extant sources, are probably the most interesting elements. Ariantes and his cohorts are appealing, three-dimensional characters. The plot makes sense, though it's a little familiar: the Evil Would-Be Celtic Queen and her druids, something Rosemary Sutcliff, Patricia Finney, etc. have all done already. Bodica doesn't actually get around to selecting a Year-King, as this character type tends to do, but one gets the feeling she might. The plot arc is a bit off, with a lot of the action skipped over and told in exposition rather than being presented with dramatic emphasis, with the result that the novel isn't as gripping as it might have been. Still, I enjoyed the book overall, and it does feature an outstanding duel scene.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Finely Drawn Characterization in Enjoyable Historical Venue, April 12 2003
This review is from: Island of Ghosts: A Novel of Roman Britain (Mass Market Paperback)
Gillian Bradford's tale of Ariantes and his Sarmatian comrades-in-arm delights in its smallness and arouses in the largeness of its message. Ariantes has swore an oath to the Roman Emperor and as a man who does not take any promise lightly, he would rather die than submit his name to dishonor. However, as a prince of a conquered people, Ariantes finds himself reduced to leading his squadron of men in the strange world of the Romans where diplomacy and deceit walk hand in hand. Ariantes' simpler life of breeding horses, making war and caring for his family disappears in the blink of an eye as he and his troops make camp on the not completely Romanized isle of Britain, near Hadrian's Wall. Yet Ariantes adapts; he finds himself negotiating for his men in matters of pay, rations and privileges and devising schemes to keep the hot headed Sarmatians from fighting amongst themselves to avoid the stricter penalties of Roman justice. As Ariantes manipulates the Roman system to better accommodate his men, he struggles to understand the customs of his conquerors and of the British tribes he and his men have sworn to simultaneously protect and keep down. Above all Ariantes remains true to himself and to what his people believe in. When he finds himself embroiled in a plot involving druids, the Pict tribe, an ambitious woman and two of his Sarmatian brothers, his true nobility is put to the test. Like her other historical novels, Island of Ghosts provides an interesting glimpse into a world where inner strength defines true courage. This portrayal of a man uprooted from his home and his assimilation into a foreign place with different values speaks universally to anyone coming in contact with a new environment. Recommended to all who love historical fiction and a strong male character who will not knuckle under political forces.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|