5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent introduction to "the Floating World", Dec 17 2008
By Michael M. Danziger - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Japanese Prints (Hardcover)
I purchased this book to learn more about those strange Japanese pictures that have funny looking people doing meaningless things and make little artistic "sense" to those of us weaned on Western aesthetics. And of course, I was also attracted by the bargain price.
After having read through most of the book, page by page, I can say that I am very much satisfied. There are typos, as mentioned in another review, but they are very few and easily overlookable. Personally, I found the essays less helpful than the commentary. If you are totally new to the subject, the first essay is just a list of names and the second essay the author's personal experience. The commentary, on the other hand, gives you explanations of the cultural/historical background, technical details about the production and biographical details about the artists. In my opinion, that is of much greater utility to one seeking familiarity with the Japanese print.
On page 36 in my edition there is an actual printing error. A line of the image, about 3mm thick is shifted to the side by a few millimeters. Also forgivable, in my opinion. The reproductions themselves are good, though after seeing more expensive museum volumes in a local library I see that this book doesn't quite offer you the level of detail that these prints deserve.
What this volume does offer you, though, is the opportunity to enter the world of the ukiyo-e. If you read through the book, you can see that the Japanese print came to be as the product of the Tokugawa shogunate closing off Japan, the improvement of printing techniques and the generation of a large middle class that would buy these prints and would participate in the world they depicted. You can also see that with the Meiji restoration and the opening of Japan, new attitudes and technologies ultimately ended the print and its surrounding world. However, the principles and aesthetics showcased in these prints continue to guide Japanese film and of course, animation, until the present.
In short, for anyone with the slightest interest in Japanese prints, this book is a must. And with such a low price, you can't go wrong.
PS - If you are looking for books of paintings, this is not a book of paintings. I feel stupid even saying that because the title of the book is "Japanese Prints" but apparently people have been confused.
43 of 58 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, April 12 2008
By Robby Krell - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Japanese Prints (Hardcover)
Don't get me wrong, the book is well produced, with a lovely dust jacket, and it's inexpensive. However, if you're looking for Hiroshige and Hokusai and the kind of pictures that I in my ignorance associate with that school of art--landscapes, cityscapes and depictions of the natural world--you will be as disappointed as I was.
There are roughly 160 pages of color plates. Great! Except that about 25 of those pages are devoted to the kind of pictures I mention above. The other 150 pagesor so are devoted to depictions of human figures, mainly women as they get dressed and apply makeup. This is an important element of Japanese art, I suppose, but it is one that does not interest me. The cover of the book, which depicts Hokusai's famous tsunami wave in front of Mt Fiji, is misleading in the extreme. Yes that picture is in the book, but as I say, for every such picture there are literally five or six pictures of geisha women combing their hair. Yawn.
I'm no expert in Japanese art; I just happened to see a small exhibit in a local museum, thought it was great, and ordered this book because I wanted to see more. I'm not interested in human figures. If you are, go for it, it's a great book. But if you're hoping for landscapes, koi fish, snowy mountainsides, views of Edo, etc, avoid this book. Or you can look for a copy at the local used bookstore, which is where I'm taking mine this afternoon.
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Typos, July 28 2008
By Boryana - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Japanese Prints (Hardcover)
The two essays included at the beginning of the book, and especially the one by Thomas Zacharias, are excellent. The prints are carefully chosen with truly wonderful commentary. For its price, this book is indeed a great bargain.
However, maybe because I love to love books too, I was very disappointed by several typos (Bhuddism, public instead of pubic hair, punctuation and one stylistic error). Too bad, since the overall quality of the book is fantastic and it is incomprehensible to me how these typos could have been overlooked.