Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Likeable, July 31 2010
This review is from: Jekel Loves Hyde (Hardcover)
When I picked up this book I liked it, but it wasn't hard to put it down until next time. I read Beth Fantaskey's other book Jessica's Guide To Dating On the Dark Side and I absolutely loved that book so I thought I would try this one. Jessica's Guide was really funny and had me pretty much glued to the pages and I was hoping for that same sentiment with Jekel Loves Hyde. This book was good, but in my opinion wasn't as good as Jessica's Guide, it didn't have the comical and humorous side that I found really appealing. Jill was so sweet and timid and the other kids were so mean to her, and Tristen was there for her right from the beginning when she didn't even know why! The story between the two of them is complicated, its hard going but there seems to always be some sort of a spark between them, and they are just not sure if they can pull out ok. Jill not only has to find trust in her family but even her closest friends for many years seem to turn on her. I liked the plot twists in this story, and they came together very well in the end and I didn't have any lingering questions as sometimes you do after reading a book. I found the last 100 pages or so I was pretty consumed with what was going on, a lot was happening. There is some mystery, love, suspense and even a little horror all mixed into this book and it was a fun read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dark, delicious teen love story! Contemporary yet classic!, July 21 2010
This review is from: Jekel Loves Hyde (Hardcover)
Beth Fantaskey is an absolutely phenomenal writer. Not only does she have a vivid imagination, but she also has a writing style that is realistically contemporary, yet classic and true to the old Jekyll and Hyde story from which her idea sprang. Her choice of words in some places is sheer beauty...poetry, as some would term it.
Jekel Loves Hyde opens with Jill Jekel feeling alone and isolated at the funeral of her father. Since his murder, her mother has had a nervous breakdown which leaves Jill in an adult role she doesn't want, paying household bills and caring for her mother. In that role there's no one to comfort and guide her, so she is surprised when a gorgeous classmate, Tristen Hyde, suddenly approaches her at the funeral, going so far as to hold her in his arms and kiss her cheek. This has been her only warm source since her father's death, so she is mortified when she breaks down and cries on his shoulder.
But when she sees him again in chemistry class and in school hallways, he has reverted to his old brooding, defiant nature.
Jill has always been an obedient daughter, but after her father's murder when he's accused of company indiscretions and she finds that her college funds have disappeared she's tempted to peek inside a mysterious box in his office. Her mother warns her against opening it.
Jill enlists Tristen's aid in discovering what's in the box because she thinks the contents might be the key to unravel his murder and discover what happened to her college funds. While working together, the teens begin to fall in love. They form a partnership and as the team of Jekel and Hyde, they recreate experiments based on the classic novel, hoping to earn the prize money for Jill's college, but also to save Tristen's sanity and perhaps his life.
Jill and Tristen are descendants of the old Robert Louis Stevenson characters of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Tristen knows this, but Jill is completely in the dark until she witnesses Tristen's dark side in a rather horrifying manner. He slowly opens up to her and tells her some of his dark secrets; she begins to believe his fantastic story.
What is haunting Tristen? What do they find in her father's box? Can the deadly concoction they are working on possibly save Tristen from becoming a monster? Is his father a monster like the original Mr. Hyde? Who killed Jill's father? How does Tristen's father use Jill's mother in his diabolical plot? But most important, why does Jill risk her own life by drinking the formula? Why does this "good girl" become "wild?"
All those questions and more are skillfully answered by this author as she weaves her magic to keep us guessing until the very end. Beth Fantaskey is Beth "Fantastic" to me!
This is listed as a Young Adult book, but I think it will appeal to adults too... It certainly does to me. Five stars and then some! It would make a block-buster horror movie.
ENDNOTE: The love scenes, while skillfully done, may be thought of as "too intense" by some parents, so keep that in mind when purchasing for your teen. But with all the other "stuff" on the market, this is mild by comparison.
Reviewed by Betty Dravis, May 16, 2010
Author of "Dream Reachers" (with Chase Von) and other books
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I Tried, But Couldn't, April 21 2010
By K. Montgomery - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Jekel Loves Hyde (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
Warning to all ye who love to vote on Amazon reviews, this is going to be the lamest one I've ever written here because I could not finish the book. I received my copy via Amazon Vine, therefore I'm obligated to do a review, which I have no problem with. I haven't been having very good luck with Vine books, though, and this time despite loving Fantaskey's debut novel, Jessica's Guide to Dating on the Dark Side, I was again left feeling listless and bored.
Jekel Loves Hyde has a great premise, being based off the classic the title emulates. I was sold. I love the concept of the original and have enjoyed movies based on it, and I sincerely dug the twist the author uses here. That's really the only expectation I had coming in, that the book might try to emulate that eerie, unrelenting sense of morbid danger the original has. And it does. Jekel Loves Hyde has a great atmosphere, but it soon became apparent to me that a great atmosphere was all it would offer this particular reader. Enough to keep me interested anyway.
I'm a character-driven reader for the most part. I love good worldbuilding, where it feels so effortless, like a cradle for the rest of the book. Once that's firmly established in the back of my mind I want to know the characters. I couldn't get into the ones here. The chapters (most of which are ridiculously short, sometimes not even two full pages hardly) alternate between Jill and Tristan's first point of view tellings. And that's the problem, I think, for me. Each tells the story. There isn't very much showing. Telling gets monotonous and after several chapters (I'm sorry, I forget what page number I stopped at), I just couldn't take it anymore. Also, when we're only ever told how a character feels, it doesn't make for very imaginative or thrilling character development.
Another thing that irked me was the intense foreshadowing - an element that I've seen in other things based on the original. Maybe this just didn't work well in fiction format for me, but in Jekel Loves Hyde, the constant foreshadowing, at the end of almost every chapter, became redundant. When the next chapter turned up yet another point of foreshadowing, I realized I was gritting my teeth a little.
The writing also wasn't up to par with the author's debut work. I'm not sure if this YA novel is targeted at a younger YA set, maybe? But I felt the writing didn't lend itself particularly well to intelligent young readers. I think that goes back to the telling aspect, which you don't need that much of. Give the readers credit, that they will "get" it when the writing shows instead of tells. I felt like I was reading a completely different author.
This was one of my most anticipated books for 2010, and I'm more sorry than I can say to be disappointed to the point of not finishing. As there's plenty more I need to read, the question came down to being miserable reading or taking a chance on the next book in my TBR. You know the answer. Two stars for the fact that I couldn't finish (which I blame myself for in spite of not enjoying), and the concept and atmosphere, which I felt was the only good thing about what I did read.
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Just an old fashioned love story, Mar 22 2010
By Travis Ann Sherman - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Jekel Loves Hyde (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
Plot: A beautiful descendant of Dr. Jekyll falls in love with the evil Mr. Hyde's descendant, who is torn between his love for her and his urge to save her from the monster he fears he is becoming.
Why I picked it up: I enjoyed Fantaskey's JESSICA'S GUIDE TO DATING ON THE DARK SIDE as a fun twist on the vampire thing.
Why I read it: The premise of a female Jekyll and a male Hyde seemed very fresh to me, a clever recasting of the always effective romantic archetypes created so many years ago by Ms. Bronte. Here our sensible Jill Jekel/Jane Eyre, a self described nerdy governess-type, falls in love with the lucious Tristen Hyde and all his dark secrets. Tristen is the only male in this school with the intelligence to see Jill's deep inner beauty and wonder what she looks like without her glasses... He finds out too.
Unfortunately, Fantaskey follows a little too closely on the frock coattails of Robert Louis Stevenson's original Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde for success. When romance rears its ugly head in the science fiction genre, it's seldom a pretty sight, and JEKEL LOVES HYDE is no exception. I wish that Fantaskey had stuck a little closer to dangerous young love and teenage angst and left the secret potions, the evil doctors,the missing ingredients and the traitorous assistants to another time and place. This plot wasn't just twisted; it was tortured too.
Who I Would Give This Book To: Someone who loves a page turner with plenty of romance.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Really wanted to like it, July 30 2010
By J. Prather - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Jekel Loves Hyde (Hardcover)
I loved this author's first YA novel. I remember thinking at the time that it was so creative and well written that it stood out among all the other paranormal books currently out there. Unfortunately, I didn't feel that way about this one. The plot just didn't make sense to me in places. Even if you have a story that has sci-fi/fantasy elements, they still have to make some sort of sense and this story just didn't. I had to struggle to complete it, and felt that the author was unable to maintain any sense of tension and drama throughout a book that should have been really creepy. The most dramatic moments in the story ended up feeling overwrought and cliched. The overall tone felt inconsistent and choppy.
I didn't buy these characters at all. They didn't sound like teenagers, didn't act like teenagers and sometimes their actions and motivations were just totally out of left field. Since I wasn't buying the characters, that meant the romance didn't work for me - I was really frustrated with Jill and very annoyed with Tristan throughout most of the novel. The dialogue is not effective, often coming across as stilted, and the extremely short chapters only served to highlight the choppy writing style.
While this one didn't work for me, I have no doubt it will find it's fan base. I am not in this novel's target group, which I think would be young adults age 15 and up. There is some language and sexual situations. Fans of paranormal romance will find things to like here, but if they also are looking for a well plotted, well written story, they will ulitmately be disappointed. Not a recommend.
|
|
|