1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Which Witch?, Mar 14 2012
By Jake and the twins - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Justice at Salem: Reexamining the Witch Trials (Paperback)
An interesting book. I found interest in the subject from a related area, a fascination with the early colonial settlements. Author worked hard to take the reader to the mind set of a colonist. The details of trials and relationships can become cumbersome. Overall a great book.
7 of 10 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Phenomenal and Eye Opening Study on Salem, Dec 25 2010
By Thomas Huff "(BlownPotential.com)" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Justice at Salem: Reexamining the Witch Trials (Paperback)
This is a fantastic little book that presents an in depth study of the Salem witch trials in 1692 and flips the persecution-of-the-innocent cliché on its head. Although the author doesn't dispute that some innocents may have been hanged (not burned as another cliché might have you believe), he instead focus on the evidence supporting the practice of said craft. (This, of course, is not to say he supports the idea that witchcraft is either real or fake, but only that it was practiced.) Mr. Cooke does this in a well-organized and easy to follow manner by narrowing the focus down to five specific trails which he feels offer the most interesting studies. Each trail occupies its own chapter in the book, weaving effective character driven narratives that could hold up as standalone stories. It should be noted that the author is a practicing lawyer and thus highly qualified to examine and scrutinize such material and he remains both informative and impartial throughout. The book is also extensively footnoted (437 citations to be exact) showing the effort and research put into this.
After reading this, my somewhat passive notions of what happened in Salem were turned upside-down; my belief that their society operated like a Monty Python sketch was transformed into a much clearer understanding of the infinitely more compelling story that actually transpired there.
Highly Recommend.
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Drifts off topic, April 12 2012
By Jenny J - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Justice at Salem: Reexamining the Witch Trials (Paperback)
I found this book while researching Tituba's role in the Salem witch trials and her subsequent representations in retellings and legends surrounding these events. While it does include information that can be backed up with other sources, there were no new theories or ideas presented. Even the last theory, that Tituba really was a witch, is a conjecture found elsewhere, especially in the minds of children reading "The Crucible" in class. My main issue with this book, however, is that it drifts off topic. In the middle of talking about Tituba being beaten by her master, it drifts off into talking about John Proctor's allegations of torture by the authorities, then suddenly to the accusations of torture--specifically water-boarding--in the modern United States. This had nothing to do with the book, and the author even admitted to straying off track, but he continued to talk about how "everyone knows that the US doesn't use torture because torture is illegal" and how water-boarding, therefore, is not torture. There is an attempt to tie this back in by saying that the dunking test used against witches (although not at Salem) is an early version of water-boarding, and therefore not torture. If I wanted to read political ideologies and opinions on investigative tactics, I would search out sources for those. A sentence to help the modern reader identify with history is one thing, entire pages on this were useless to the current argument (that Tituba was a witch). I came to this book for historical analysis, nothing more.