Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Let's not sell 'em short!, Jun 16 2004
This review is from: Kansas (Audio CD)
Like most people, it was The Best of Kansas and Leftoverture which caught my interest in this band. Prog-rock with an edge, without getting too lost in it's own grandiosity. But it was this self-titled debut which sold me lock, stock and barrel. A little bit of everything here-- well crafted balladry ("Lonely Wind"), gritty jam-rock ("Can I Tell You"), railing heavy metal ("Belexes", "The Death of Mother Nature Suite") and uplifting art-rock ("Journey from Mariabronn", "Apercu"). "Apercu" is certainly the album's center piece, and it's lamentable that we never hear it on Kansas' live sets these days. On the other hand, "Belexes" and "Journey" still do, and we even occasionaly hear the J.J. Cale cover, "Bringing it Back", from time to time. This last is more than a cover-- it's so deftly arrainged that Kansas has made it their own. The only weak track is "The Pilgrimage", but it's not nearly weak enough to strip the album of ANY stars. Kansas really doesn't have any bad albums, but some rise above others. This is one of them. If you're just taking an interest in classic rock, or just in Kansas, this isn't a bad place to start, as long as you keep in mind the time period in which it was concieved.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
The two faces of Kansas, Feb 10 2004
This review is from: Kansas (Audio CD)
Although the liner notes suggest that this music has many faces, I would settle for just two: namely that of hard rock and progressive rock. While not very much to my liking, I have to admit that the hard rock tracks on the CD (Can I tell You; Bringing it Back; Belexes; and The Pilgrimage) exhibit barely discernible traces of sophisticated harmonic and rhythmic interplay. In stark contrast to this huge slab of thunderous hard rock, the delicate Lonely Wind is borne simply on the acoustic piano with a stately bass/drum accompaniment and tasteful violin leads. Things do not get really interesting however until reaching the fifth track, Journey from Mariabronn, which is a full-blown work of progressive rock. Much to my delight, the guys (probably Livgren) employ a whole-tone scale at the end of this piece, which is very cool indeed. The crowning glory of this debut however is the excellent, 9'45 Apercu. All of the elements of classic prog are here: complex ensemble work, intricate synthesizer leads, imaginative arrangements, and great vocal parts. The blazing finale, Death of Mother Nature Suite, is also quite good and is the most seamless fusion of hard rock and prog on the disc. While not essential, some folks may find that this debut is worth shelling out the 10 bucks just for Lonely Wind; Journey from Mariabronn; Apercu; and Death of Mother Nature Suite.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Kansas Beginnings, Sep 26 2003
This review is from: Kansas (Audio CD)
On Kansas' self-titled debut KANSAS (1974), we are already treated to their unique blend of heartland rock, boogie, country, and symphonic rock. Of course, they would refine their compositions on subsequent albums, but what they created on this debut here is highly impressive and enjoyable on it's own merits. The band had already been playing together a few years before the release of this album (the band even stated that they had 50 combined years of musical experience in the sleeve), so this may contribute to the impressive gelling of ideas, and overall, accomplished musicianship exhibited here. The first half of the album features more of the stripped-down tracks that Kansas seemed to exhibit from time to time, while the second half seems to be dedicated to the elaborate prog-rock epics. The album starts of with the fairly simple, but utterly addicting, violin-laced "Can I Tell You." Contrary to the opinion expressed by another reviewer, I don't find this, or any of the other tracks on this album, weak. Sure, it isn't a *prog* track in the Kansas tradition (if Kansas really ever had a tradition), but, different doesn't necessarily equal weak (opinions are subjective, not fact, folks.) However, while I enjoy this track immensely, I find the unissued demo version found on the KANSAS BOXED SET to be a more enjoyable version for me. "Bringing It Back" sounds like something you'd hear a bar-band performing. Reminds me of a slightly tame, underdeveloped prototype for the kind of thing you'd hear on SONG FOR AMERICA (1975) ("Down The Road" in particular comes to mind), but the underdevelopedness doesn't sink the track's tasteful edibility. I find it impressive how some bands (Queen, Rush, Kansas etc.) can make raw, underdeveloped music - that is, the music they make before reaching their peak in sound and/or composition - yet what they come up with on first shot seems to be much more impressive than what some artists produce in their entire catalogues. "Lonely Wind" is a beautiful ballad penned by Steve Walsh. The vocal harmonies on this track are particularly moving, added with the melancholic piano, and soothing violin lines. The perfect song to be played for the bride & groom on their wedding day, while having a slow dance. On "Belexes," we are treated to the most energetic, rocking song on this set at this point. A definite rock-your-socks-off track, featuring some crunchy guitar lines, passionate, inspired vocals, and drumming that isn't too shabby. "Journey From Mariabronn" starts off the second half as a classically-inspired number. This is probably the most compelling track on the album - compositionally speaking. The opening instrumental section, which lasts for 1 1/2 minute -- an energetic, mysterious section of band interplay leaving the listener in suspenseful anticipation, followed by an anthemic, soaring, worldly passage comprised of complex polyphony fronted by stately violin, which is then followed by a section in about 5/4 -- is one of the defining moments in Kansas' career. The song is all-around brilliant in my book. "The Pilgrimage" is a tasteful, fluid, mix of R&B and mild country influences. The melody, the lines and the vocal harmonies brings slight resemblance to Yes, particularly their track "I've Seen All Good People." A definite favorite of mine on this album. "Apercu" is another elaborate prog-rock epic, which even features a romp section which resembles that of the romp-like section in "Cheyenne Anthem" from LEFTOVERTURE (1976). The instrumental virtuosity and quirky elements displayed here are definite attributes which foreshadow things to be found in later albums. "Death of Mother Nature Suite" is a fine effort, but the unissued live version found on the KANSAS BOXED SET is much more enjoyable and fluid for me. This probably isn't the album to start out with if you're new to Kansas. Start with LEFTOVERTURE (1976) and POINT OF KNOW RETURN (1977), then move onto their first three albums: this one, SONG FOR AMERICA (1975), and MASQUE (1975).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|