Most helpful customer reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
an adolscent luv story, Jun 7 2004
This review is from: Kartography (Hardcover)
a recommendation on a discussin forum, brought my attention to his piece, and I kept postpoing it. My first attempt at kartography , got it from my library 2 weeks, a 14 day book. Started out dry in the begging, with Karim and Raheen two kids, aged 14, go for holidays to Aunt Laila's farm. They both of them have an epiphany they aren't clear about. karim a Bengali, decides to overlook, either having an inkling of the facts wheras Raheen is curious, asks her uncle until a fight one day, makes her decide she is never going to enquire on the topic again. As to how detrimental it is to have dead secrets buried, more so for the secrets to remain buried, shows up a decade, there's more buried under, thatz been blocked out, and one fine day the truth is out in the open and a shocker, as to why Karim and Raheen could never become one, inspite of their undying love for each other. The book starts out at an excellent pace after Raheen's grown up and studying in NY, and they show her reading that romantic stuff, from that part on, I couldn't stop reading , till I finished. It was such an enjoyable read. And towards the end She really messed it up like in the beginning where it's all about tying loose end. I had to read the parental generation story twice or thrice before I understood the gist of what happened. Karim and Raheen once grown up , was the wonderful part to read. All those child - age realizations didn't really impress me. Worth a read, once wish there was more of spice. more of a tale, and really there were more personal rants, with the story being narrated in backdrops.. specially the partition scene made a comeback for a very brief period of time. .. But I guess it could have been edited a lot more, most of those adolescent scenes could have been dropped in order to make way for an impressive romance between Karim and Raheen. I kept waiting for more, and more.. and well.. it was disappointing..
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
An adolscent love, strengthened by age., Jun 7 2004
This review is from: Kartography (Hardcover)
a recommendation on a discussin forum, brought my attention to his piece, and I kept postpoing it. My first attempt at kartography , got it from my library 2 weeks, a 14 day book. Started out dry in the begging, with Karim and Raheen two kids, aged 14, go for holidays to Aunt Laila's farm. They both of them have an epiphany they aren't clear about. karim a Bengali, decides to overlook, either having an inkling of the facts wheras Raheen is curious, asks her uncle until a fight one day, makes her decide she is never going to enquire on the topic again. As to how detrimental it is to have dead secrets buried, more so for the secrets to remain buried, shows up a decade, there's more buried under, thatz been blocked out, and one fine day the truth is out in the open and a shocker, as to why Karim and Raheen could never become one, inspite of their undying love for each other. The book starts out at an excellent pace after Raheen's grown up and studying in NY, and they show her reading that romantic stuff, from that part on, I couldn't stop reading , till I finished. It was such an enjoyable read. And towards the end She really messed it up like in the beginning where it's all about tying loose end. I had to read the parental generation story twice or thrice before I understood the gist of what happened. Karim and Raheen once grown up , was the wonderful part to read. All those child - age realizations didn't really impress me. Worth a read, once wish there was more of spice. more of a tale, and really there were more personal rants, with the story being narrated in backdrops.. specially the partition scene made a comeback for a very brief period of time. .. But I guess it could have been edited a lot more, most of those adolescent scenes could have been dropped in order to make way for an impressive romance between Karim and Raheen. I kept waiting for more, and more.. and well.. it was disappointing..
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Engaging, Witty and Astute: But tread slowly, May 8 2004
This review is from: Kartography (Hardcover)
Kamila Shamsie's third novel, "Kartography" is an engaging, witty, yet strangely endearing story. Raheen and Karim, members of Karachis elite privileged class, are soul mates from birth, but after Karims move abroad they somehow drift apart, yet hold onto memories forever. On his return, Raheen seeks to understand what possibly could have caused the divide between their hearts; Karim seems accusatory, speaks in a language she cannot understand, and is trying to tell her something that she does not know of. In between their complicated love and friendship, there are haunts of an earlier relationshop; Karims and Raheens parents were once engaged to each other, until "the music changed". Why this happened, and how it affected their childrens lives, Raheen asks and explores, until she is told the truth and her world and literally everything she stood for, collapses. In the larger political and social backdrop is the Civil war between East and West Pakistan that divided the nation into two. This story, set in the later 80's and early 90s sees Karachi, their beloved city, torn apart by strife and violence. Should this affect their relationship? Raheen chooses to accept it while Karim feels the pain and demands Raheen to understand it in context. Kamila Shamsie's writing is extremely engaging and humorous, with a shrewd understanding of society and people, at times; although she can be confusing and rewuire readers to read over to fully understand the meaning. Conversations don't always seem real; the characters speak in drawn out sentences and in a literary, philosophical manner, which can be annoying at times (nobody speaks in words like "palimpsest"). The book refers only to a very very minute selection of Karachi society, the extreme elite who live outside the circles that define mainstream Karachi. However, despite the confusion and constant energy and action that can be taxing to your understanding of the plot and following of the story, Kartography is extremely enjoyable, overall very well written and astute. While not particularly deep, as novels go, its definitely worth its price.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|