From Booklist
Gr. 7^-12. In the style of Boas'
We Are Witnesses: The Diaries of Five Teenagers Who Died in the Holocaust , Lyons weaves her own commentary and analysis with quotes from the girlhood diaries of seven nineteenth-century women writers: Louisa May Alcott, Charlotte Forten, Sarah Jane Foster, Kate Chopin, Alice Dunbar-Nelson, Ida B. Wells, and Charlotte Perkins Gilman. A center inset includes one small photo of each of the seven. Lyons writes with style and feeling, creating a strong sense of each individual life story, even as she gives us a social history of what it was like to be a woman at that time. We see young people caught between public docility and private anger. Lyons is admiring without being adulatory; for example, she laments Alcott's narrow vision ("she could have been much more" ) and wishes that Forten had gone beyond the "19th century woman's garden--marriage, motherhood, and religion." Lyons shows that the very act of keeping a diary helped these women take risks and explore dangerous feelings until each was able to find a voice of her own. Any teen who keeps a journal will recognize what the title implies: the private world behind the mask of duty. Notes; bibliography.
Hazel Rochman
Review
"A collection of seven literary biographies liberally sprinkled with brief quotations from the subjects’ diaries, written when they were young adults." --School Library Journal, starred review