Last Herald Mage Trilogy #2 Magics Promise [Mass Market Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

The Last Herald-Mage trilogy continues with this second novel, in which Vanyel has accepted his responsibilities as a Herald and has aged, not only in years but also in experience. Gone is the whiny and insecure teenager we knew from the previous book, replaced by an older and wiser man, one who has seen far too many battles, and far too many dear friends fall in the line of duty.

We have, in short, someone who's quite earned his chance to be a nervous wreck.

What starts off in a fairly boring way (Vanyel returning to his family home for a rest) quickly gets the action going when he and his Companion receive an urgent call for help, and quickly get embroiled in a murder investigation, political and magical assassination, and something that, improperly handled, could devestate more than two countries with a spectacularly large and magically-triggered earthquake.

Business as usual, then.

When I'd first read this series, I was much younger, in my teens, and this book was my least favourite of the trilogy. Now I find myself liking it a lot more, partially because I can relate a little more to the adult that Vanyel has become. While this doesn't necessarily say much for Lackey's ability to convey characters well to any age group, it does speak well for her ability to create characters that readers of certain age groups can relate to.

If there's anything that really grated on me while reading this, it was Vanyel's identity crisis. He goes through a period of not being able to figure out if he's really homosexual or just happened to hall in love with a man. Which, on its own, may sound like a wise thing to ponder, but half the time, the way he went about it made me want to smack him on the head. Consider the time he's in disguise and is being pawed at by a rather despicable woman, who turns his stomach, and then is hit on by a creepy man who gives him the same reaction. He spends the next few pages wondering why, if he's really gay, didn't he just give in to the man hitting on him, and if he's not gay, why doesn't he just sleep with the woman the way she wants. And it took him over half the book to figure out, "Oh right, being gay doesn't mean I'll automatically hop into bed with every single male I come across." Admittedly, he chastises himself for forgetting then what he knew so well when he was young, that sex and love are different things and that he prefers love, or at least affection, to go along with sex, but still. Hearing him debate over and over again whether or not he's really gay just wore on my nerves after a while, and it got frustrating to read.

I still enjoyed the book, following along with the murder mystery and piecing together little clues myself (that's the fun of reading about mysteries, after all), but frankly, this book could have been cut from the trilogy without affecting the main plot very much. It's good for building character, for tying up some minor loose ends, for introducing a character or two that will play minor parts later on, but aside from emotional healing, it doesn't play a very large part in Vanyel's story. More could have been written about him battles on the Karsite border, I think, and have been more important to the plot of the trilogy as a whole.

The second in Mercedes Lackey's "The Last Herald-Mage" trilogy, this book is part of my all-time favorite trilogy on earth. This book is amazing, though not my favorite of the trilogy (that goes to "Magic's Pawn"), and it is definitely a worthy sequel. Buy this if you read gay OR fantasy fiction, because it is absolutely worth it.

This is the second book in Mercedes Lackey's best trilogy. Also beautifully written, this book takes place years after the first one. The only thing this book lacks is romance. But don't worry! The romance returns full force in book three!

In this book, Vanyel has already become a famous, respected and admired Herald-Mage. There is no herald who commands power as he does, and he struggles with inner demons of love for his friends.

Out of all three books, this one holds the most action. Vanyel continues to grow in this book, building toward the character he will end up as in the last one.

Did you enjoy Magic's Pawn? Don't hesitate, buy this book -- it's an amazing read. You'll love it. And when you finish this one, you get to look forward to reading the last one...the best one of all.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 39 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

 

5.0 out of 5 stars Wonderfully written!
This is the second book in Mercedes Lackey's best trilogy. Also beautifully written, this book takes place years after the first one. Read more

Published on Nov 9 2003 by E. Pan

4.0 out of 5 stars Vanyel rides again
In "Magic's Promise," Vanyel Ashkevron is tired. He's been doing the work of five full Herald-mages, and desperately needs some R&R.

Does he get it? Well . . . no. Read more

Published on July 3 2003 by Barb Caffrey

5.0 out of 5 stars Heart Breakingly Beautiful!
I went straight into Magic Promise after Magic Pawn. Magic Promise is just as spell binding. Not because of the fantasy aspects or the magic because I have read more imaginative... Read more

Published on Feb 26 2003 by R.Parklane

3.0 out of 5 stars A derivative, but slightly improved sequel.
A boy who lives in the holding of Forst Reach who is the black sheep of the family, bullied by the armsmaster, and who's only real talent and ambition lies in music. Read more

Published on Feb 11 2003 by Jason C. Hill

1.0 out of 5 stars If you like to see your heroes DO something.
Then don't buy this book.
This books picks up like 15 years after the one before.
At the end of the last book, Van met the bad guy and killed him. Read more

Published on Jan 31 2003 by Jason A. Myers

5.0 out of 5 stars an awesome continuation
keeping on with the character of vanyel, the last herald-mage, mercedes lackey does a wonderful job with suspense, action, basically everything. ms. Read more

Published on Nov 25 2002 by skyeatssoul

5.0 out of 5 stars In some ways better then the first!
The second in the Harald-Mage series is very different from the first. The thing I noticed right off is that Vanyel has a sence of humor! Read more

Published on Sep 22 2002

5.0 out of 5 stars As good as the first, which is hard to get
This is the second book, and I loved it as much as the first. Vanyel is older now, and more mature; a battle-seasoned veteran fresh off the lines. Read more

Published on Sep 17 2002 by Amberblade

4.0 out of 5 stars A Fun Magical Mystery
Vanyel has now become the most powerful Herald-Mage in all of Valdemar. In the ten or so years that have passed since the end of "Magic's Pawn," Vanyel has defeated numerous... Read more

Published on July 10 2002 by Leanna

5.0 out of 5 stars Vanyel is maturing nicely in this one...
The first book in the trilogy, "Magic's Pawn," introduced us to protagonist Vanyel as an adolescent struggling to figure out who he is in the greater world. Read more

Published on May 7 2002 by knightsky

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 39 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

Search Listmania!