| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
|
Biographer Ronald Huntford's attempt to restore Amundsen to glory, first published in 1979 under the title Scott and Amundsen, has been thawed as part of the Modern Library Exploration series, captained by Jon Krakauer (of Into Thin Air fame). The Last Place on Earth is a complex and fascinating account of the race for this last great terrestrial goal, and it's pointedly geared toward demythologizing Scott. Though this was the age of the amateur explorer, Amundsen was a professional: he left little to chance, apprenticed with Eskimos, and obsessed over every detail. While Scott clung fast to the British rule of "No skis, no dogs," Amundsen understood that both were vital to survival, and they clearly won him the Pole.
Amundsen in Huntford's view is the "last great Viking" and Scott his bungling opposite: "stupid ... recklessly incompetent," and irresponsible in the extreme--failings that cost him and his teammates their lives. Yet for all of Scott's real or exaggerated faults, he understood far better than Amundsen the power of a well-crafted sentence. Scott's diaries were recovered and widely published, and if the world insisted on lionizing Scott, it was partly because he told a better story. Huntford's bias aside, it's clear that both Scott and Amundsen were valiant and deeply flawed. "Scott ... had set out to be an heroic example. Amundsen merely wanted to be first at the pole. Both had their prayers answered." --Svenja Soldovieri
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product)
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amundsen isn't without faults either,
By
This review is from: The Last Place on Earth (Paperback)
Obviously, those who can't find fault with Robert Falcon Scott won't like the book. If you are one of those, read "The Coldest March" by Susan Solomon. You'll find it to your taste.
However, if you are ready for a solid analysis about how Roal Amundsen and Scott each organized and faced their heroic voyage to the South Pole, THIS is the book to read. The book covers Amundsen's and Scott's origins and background in Polar travel (Scott badly overmatched there). When Amundsen learned from previous voyages, namely his NorthWest Passage succes and the Belgica's wintering inside the Antarctic's circle, Scott still hung to man-hauling, having learned absolutly NOTHING from his Discovery days. The paradox with Scott lies in the fact that so-called "impartial" historians who praised him has a "scientific-minded" explorer cannot explain why this "scientific-minded" navy officer still had his crew travel like cavemen in horrific conditions. Amundsen isn't without faults either. His treatment of Haljmar Johansen for instance wasn't very gracious to say the least. I'll let you draw you own conclusion, but,for my taste, Roland Huntford analysis is the definite work on the South Polar Race of 1911-1912.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome chronicle of Victorian Era Polar exploration..,
By
This review is from: The Last Place on Earth (Paperback)
Huntford's research into the contrasting quests for the South Pole in 1911 is based upon multiple diaries and private letters. His narrative is compelling, giving a 'you-are-there' feel -- a real page-turner. I had viewed the DVD 'Last Place on Earth' several times, and found the book (the foundation of the BBC series) a perfect complement. Interestingly, attitudes or faults which led to the failure of the British expedition led by Falcon Scott, are elucidated in painstaking detail, but the same event in the film version has to be covered in a brief scene. I was astounded by the skill of the BBC cinematographers after reading Huntford's account. Anyone who (still) thinks that Scott was an intelligent, brave leader who perished with his men due to unexpected bad weather needs to read this book. Also, Amundsen's skill, meticulous preparation, and steely determination to succeed are vetted thoroughly. A must-read for fans of this genre.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Should be a classic.,
By A Customer
This review is from: The Last Place on Earth (Paperback)
Controversial perhaps, but also an exceptionaly well-researched, page-turner story. The author, Roland Huntford has also written several other biographies, all of which stand at the top of the large heap of related polar-exploration books. This book was renamed from "Scott & Amundsen" after a PBS series was produced, based on this account -- which used the new title. I strongly recommend reading this, and if you believe that the author takes a biased view (against Scott) then you should read on to the many other accounts available.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Want to see more reviews on this item?
|
Most recent customer reviews |
|
|
|