2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Intriguing!, May 14 2011
By Robin Jacobson - Published on Amazon.com
At one point in The Last Rain, Edeet Ravel's intriguing and revealing novel, Dori, the six-year old narrator, reflects that she doesn't like books that are hybrids: a book with photographs should be about things that really happened and not tell invented stories. In a playful move, the author follows this comment with a photograph from what appear to be her own archives, showing her at Dori's age. She captions the photo "genre confusion."
This is one of many gently humorous and playful touches in this clever, hybrid novel, set on a kibbutz in the 1950s. The author makes it clear, both in her foreword and through the use of external material, that her novel is in many ways a memoir, but she has chosen to present her story through fiction, thus allowing for multiple points of view and layers of meaning. The novel includes notes in which the writer herself appears in an instant messaging conversation with someone called "Nissim" in which she seems to be discussing the process of writing the novel.
The novel is both fascinating and moving. Dori's mother keeps a diary in which the challenges of feeding a newborn who lives in a communal Children's House are shown to be to some degree insurmountable; forced to distance herself from her daughter, the mother begins to refer to her baby as "the girl." A diary kept by a young man on one of the first kibbutzim, in the 1920s, is a revelation. Most prominent, however, is the collective diary of the kibbutz founders, who in stunningly lyrical prose, and with surprising honesty, describe their exuberance as well as their guilt about usurping the inhabitants of what was, until a few months before their arrival, an Arab town.
Characters are developed through comical autobiographical fiction (Dori's father), excerpts from an amateur play (Dori's mother), kibbutz meetings, and above all through Dori's captivating voice. Dori's life, like that of her fellow kibbutz members, is filled with hardship, and the echoes of tragedy are everywhere, but the author's sense of irony and deft comic touch never falter, and promote the message which appears at the end of the acknowledgements: "No one here is leaving, so we had better start loving." For anyone interested in utopian movements, human folly, Israel's history, and in a child's take on it all, this novel is a must.
5.0 out of 5 stars
superbly written, May 21 2011
By Janos Juhasz - Published on Amazon.com
This is one of the best books I've read in a while -- a kibbutz is built on the ruins of an Arab village by a group of idealistic Jews from North America and the results are portrayed in striking detail by one of the children. The socialist enterprise is barely holding itself together at first, but sixty years later it's running a billion dollar industry. Highly recommended - you'll discover things about the kibbutz you never imagined.