Laurel & Hardy: The Essential Collection

 

 

Create your own review

For whatever reason, my first attempt to publish a review on this site failed (I entered it almost 2 weeks ago!). I'm hoping it was just a glitch as I did not use any profanity, or anything beyond constructive criticism in my review! Below is the exact wording of my subsequent review (minus the last line of it, which isn't relevant here) that was published on amazon.com seconds after I entered it. I hope for it to be helpful:

Aside from the no-brainer five star rating, I don't really have much to add to what has already been stated regarding the set's contents. My only issue is that I have seldom (if ever) heard so much carping about packaging as I have for this set! Yes, there were two discs in mine that required a bit of wiping. Apart from that, they play just fine, thank you! I actually rather like the packaging, as it doesn't take up a lot of space, and is environmentally friendly compared to other, ridiculously bulky packaging designs. As far as I am concerned, the real bane as far as DVDs and/or packaging go are the dreaded double-sided discs. Whoever thought that this relic from the golden age of vinyl belonged in the digital age ought to have their head examined! Dual layer makes that totally unnecessary! As far as conventional packaging is concerned, I have occasionally had DVDs arrive in the mail, only to find the disc shaking inside the case because the centerpiece holding the disc in place busted. At least with the packaging for the Laurel & Hardy set, that is definitely not a concern!

I regret taking up so much space discussing the packaging rather than the contents. It's just that there have been far more negative comments about it than it actually deserves, in my opinion!

I am very thankful that amazon.com has restocked Laurel & Hardy: The Essential Collection (though I ordered mine through amazon.ca). It had allegedly been pulled due to "too many returns." It seemed to me that based on comments by the loudest critics of the packaging that some returned their sets without even playing any of the discs! For Region 1 based Laurel & Hardy fans who have been waiting so long for a marvelous set like this, that don't want it to disappear, I implore you to at least try playing the discs first (at the very least, fast forward through all the titles!) before deciding whether a return shipment is warranted!

This ten-DVD set has the complete sound output from the boys' tenure at the Hal Roach studios...the picture quality varies, but the restorations for the most part are excellent. Stan and Babe have never looked or sounded better. I would have paid full price just for "Our Relations", which is finally at long last on home video in North America. Throw in the foreign language (and in some cases longer) versions of their films, plus guest appearances and so on and you have a collection that will make L&H fans ecstatic. Packaged like a book (with extensive liner notes), it actually takes up less space than the L&H VHS tapes I bought years ago. As they used to say --- accept no substitutes. THIS IS THE REAL DEAL!!!

This Laurel & Hardy: The Essential Collection is excellent in every way. I can gurrantee you a belly laugh every minute. I have no hesitation in recommending purchase of this product.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 7 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

 

2.0 out of 5 stars Thank you for the warning on the bad packaging
Thank you 'Robert Badgley' for the warning on the sub-standard packaging. I am so fed up with dvd's arriving scratched and scuffed from packaging such as you have described. Read more

Published 6 months ago by Anthony D

5.0 out of 5 stars Hooray for the BOYS
Yes indeed, the BOYS are here in grand form. A big 5 stars for the content. Absolutely THE BEST comedy team EVER. I love these guys.

Published 7 months ago by egbert rousselle

5.0 out of 5 stars How about the content of the DVD's Mr. B. ^^^^^ ?
This item is being delivered to me today and I'm not writing this as a review, but as a retort to the guy above me, who, so gracefully, gave us his review of the films. Read more

Published 7 months ago by Chris

1.0 out of 5 stars RHI blows it with sub-par packaging!
Let's start by saying that this reviewer is one of THE biggest fans of the Boys.Without a doubt they are arguably THE best comedy film team of all time and I,like SO many other... Read more

Published 7 months ago by Robert Badgley

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 7 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

Search Listmania!