A Legend of Zelda: A link to the past is one of my all time favourite games, and I bought this new one very excitedly, but, of course, also very hesitantly. I did not want them to mess up my idealistic memories of the original, but I really wanted a continuation to the story.
So, let me tell you, that this game (so far, as I am still not done), has made me very happy. Of all things, one of the things that has made me happiest about the game is it acts and feels like the original, including the fact that they are doing the "from the sky" view, as opposed to "from behind" like the newer games do. This gives it this wonderfully nostalgic feel to it, and I absolutely loved it.
The story itself is just as interesting as the first, the graphics, are bang on to what I want, a nice combination of great graphics from our current technology, and old style from the original.
If you have any one who loves the Legend of Zelda series, this is an absolute must, and even if you aren't a fan of the series, but love Link to the Past, this is an absolute must.
Should you buy? yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.