I asked a number of holocaust survivors how they felt about the movie. Most of the them found it beautiful, they realize that it is unrealistic but the fantasy in it moved them. Of course, there were some people who did not accept it as the scars in them were too deep. But such things are to be expected. However, if one watches the DVD extras and sees the effect in the Simon Wiesenthal center, one sees that this movie has an overall positive impact among a lot of the Holocaust survivors. As far as Steven Spielberg not liking it, well, he may be a gifted director, but he is not the sole authority on the Holocaust just because he has made one movie on it. His movie is ripped off from one of the most gifted writers, Thomas Keneally. When he comes up with a story with imagination, he can talk. I have read numerous books on the Holocaust and talked to survivors and understand that this is not reality. But, it still makes you appreciate the story without undermining the Holocaust in anyway whatsoever. That is the magic of the movie.
There are a number of special scenes in this movie. Particular among them are how he shields his son, Joshua from the Nazis Nuremberg laws - "We will not allow spiders and visigoths into our shop from tomorrow".Read more ›
I asked a number of my friends who have been through the Holocaust what they felt about the movie. Most of them loved the movie though they said that it was extremely unrealistic. Some of them could not stomach it, their scars were too deep. However, that is to be expected. I have read a number of books on the Holocaust and read the reaction to this movie from the Jerusalem Film Festival and the Simon Wiesenthal Center, most of it was overwhelmingly positive. I saw that Steven Spielberg did not like the movie, well he may be a gifted directed, but making one movie on the Holocaust does not make him an authority on the subject. His movie was ripped off from one of the most gifted authors of our times - Thomas Keneally. If you read the book, the movie will pale in comparison. This movie on the other hand, has creativity and fantasy that the ordinary movie.
One important thing about this movie is the way he mocks the fascists. In an opening sequence, he finds himself in a runaway car and sticks out an arm to protect himself -- only to confuse himself with the saluting Fascists who are also in town.Read more ›