1.0 out of 5 stars
$$$, April 14 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: A Life God Rewards: Why Everything You Do Today Matters Forever (Hardcover)
This book is way overpriced. I feel that if this is meant to be an inspiring book it should be written for everyone, everyone including those who can afford 10 dollars on a tiny book. WWJD? would He charge people 10 bucks for inspiring them? I highly doubt it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poor offering from Wilkinson, Jan 22 2004
This review is from: A Life God Rewards: Why Everything You Do Today Matters Forever (Hardcover)
This book frankly amazed me. I was amazed at the price for such a small book; and even more surprised by Wilkinson's central thesis, that what we do here on Earth affects how we are rewarded in Heaven. The book seems to have basked in nothing but positive reviews - which are simply misleading. I know this is popular teaching in the US - less so in the UK. Why write a theological book when you can get to the top of the NY Times Bestsellers list with this?
Wilkinson organises the book around two "keys" to eternal reward. The first key is belief (chapters seven onwards), and the second is how our works affect our repayment in Heaven (chapters one to six).
The author presents a number of interesting concepts - such as the idea of property ownership in Heaven:
"What is surprising is what Jesus promises a faithful steward of His treasure. It is not, as you might expect, that you'll steward more treasure in Heaven, but that you will own it." (p. 86)
Wilkinson's argument rests upon the verse in Matthew 6: 19-20:
"Lay not up for yourselves treasures upon earth, where moth and rust doth corrupt, and where thieves break through and steal: 20 But lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust doth corrupt, and where thieves do not break through nor steal..."
The problem some might have with this verse is Wilkinson's literal interpretation of it. Surely the treasure in Heaven is to be able to worship God continually. Without evangelism...?
There are a number of other ideas, which are cause for concern.
For example, in 'Hell by Degrees' (p.97), the author 'demonstrates' how eternal punishment is related to how bad we have been on Earth. However, I think for me, Wilkinson's understanding of Hell is woefully inadequate. How would his argument stand up if we begin to conceptualise hell as simply being the eternal absence of God? What worse punishment could there be than that? Would Wilkinson modify his argument along the lines of Very bad=No access to God, Just a bit bad=some access to God? It is submitted that that just does not hold water.
Tough questions such as: "will directing your giving to a high-profile civic fund please Him as much as giving it top your church's missions fund?" (p.88), miss the mark, and do little to encourage social action.
But then, not completely unexpectedly, Wilkinson seems to spot the problem with his argument, and adds that belief fills the gaps that our good works miss. A bit like Tort fills the gaps in contract. Since, "no amount of good works can save us" (p.97).
So where are we left at the end of the book? Well, I was confused by Wilkinson's contradictions. I understand the points he sought to make, but the Bible verses and other quotations were shoehorned in, as if to prove his points. God's grace is almost completely overlooked - something find rather odd. This book comes in no less than seven different English-language editions. Why? It's more of a door wedge than a doorstop.
Wilkinson's focus is on Heaven being the goal: but I would argue that God's glory is the goal - Heaven's the bonus.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
Give for what you can get., Jan 9 2004
This review is from: A Life God Rewards: Why Everything You Do Today Matters Forever (Hardcover)
Synopsis: God will reward you 10,000 fold in heaven for what you give up and away in this life. If you want to learn much else you may learn a lot more elsewhere.
You likely won't get a good return on giving from a motive of greed for heavenly rewards and stature as this book came across to me as promoting. The book would have done well to inspire a motive of love from a pure heart as the reason for giving.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No