10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Life of Pi, Oct 15 2005
I finished reading Yann Martel's 'The Life of Pi' a few days ago, and I'm clearly at least three years too late. With all the hype heaped on the book after it won the prestigious Booker Prize, and the reams of rave reviews (from Canada and around the world) that followed, I expected something pretty good. What I found was a decent novel, but nothing spectacular or important. Sure, coming from the Canadian literary environment dominated by Margaret Atwood and Alice Munro, 'The Life of Pi' was a fresh and exciting find. It was unexpected. But now that the freshness has worn off, and the novel's main conceit has been dispersed all around the internet, it's painfully clear that Martel's book isn't anything special.
The main flaw of 'The Life of Pi' is obvious to anyone who's read the book, regardless of whether they want to admit it or not. There simply isn't enough story, character or idea to fill a novel. 'The Life of Pi' is based on one gimmick and has only one developed character. And despite an overlong beginning that tries to flesh things out, it's all too clear that you're only reading the novel for its final third. The rest is filler and, while sometimes interesting (the parts on animal behaviour and zoos are fun to read), seems to be there only because, well, other books have beginnings and no one will buy a sixty-page novel. In a cruel twist, the best-written and most rewarding part of the first half of the book is the prologue, in the neat form of an author's note.
Another problem is the writing style. Martel writes literature in a way that calls attention to itself as literature, instead of just telling a story. As a result, too many parts of the novel are self-important and wordy. It's a good thing that he has talent then, because sometimes his style works, and the book starts to flow and becomes a pleasure to read. These moments are just too rare to elevate the thin story.
But whatever Martel's shortcomings, 'The Life of Pi' is still eons ahead of most of the hackery that sells like mad these days (I'm looking at you, Dan Brown!). It's a mildly fascinating (and surprisingly gruesome) tale of survival on the high seas that manages to weave religion, science fiction and day-to-day monotony into something that is ultimately thematically rich. However, unlike the old Indian character who claims he can tell a story that will make someone believe in God, Martel's story is more about the role of stories, legends and myths in a society that is leaning evermore toward cold, boring facts than a discussion of religion. It is as a parable about the need for embellishment and imagination that 'The Life of Pi' is most successful and valuable.
Jesus, Mary, Mohammed and Vishnu bless Yann Martel for that.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A life unlike any other, Nov 4 2002
Yann Martel's novel takes us from a small community in India to the middle of the Pacific Ocean, where a boy and a tiger share a lifeboat and develop, if not a friendship, a unique understanding of one another. The novel begins slowly and I wasn't sure if I was going to like it, but I also couldn't put it down, especially once on the high seas. Like any seafaring tale, it may be "tall" in parts, and you can, if you wish, choose to believe an alternate story provided for you near the end, but I prefer the taller of the two tales, and was bleary-eyed but well rewarded for reading it in one long sitting.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful piece of literature!, Dec 5 2002
This is one of the most powerful novels I have ever read. It begins with a section that builds up the main character flawlessly. Then it shifts to wonderfully written story of survival, exploring almost every angle of human nature in the face of adversity. It delves into relationships in the most interesting of ways, and makes one think twice about their own. The third and final section of the book brings a bit of a twist in the plot; it left me enjoying the book in it's entirity even more. It is one of those feel good books, which I could not put down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No