6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Not so true story, Mar 9 2004
This review is from: The Long Walk: The True Story of a Trek to Freedom (Paperback)
Odd that Rawicz's Mongolians walk everywhere rather than ride horses, and dress in conical hats (something no one else has observed). Odd that he claims to have gone for 12 days in the Gobi without water - he must have been ready for a beer or two after that. And perhaps he had consumed more than a couple of beers when he met the yetis in the high Himalayas.
It's also odd that Rawicz has refused to authenticate any of his claims and declined to produce records, photographs, witnesses, or the full identity or whereabouts of the other survivors.
I think the bit on the cover, which claims that this is a "true story", may need revising.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Fake, lie, ridiculous., Feb 22 2011
For all those who are amazed by this book I have to tell one thing- never take anything for granted. Question everything. You won't eat spoiled food, right? Why would you read a book that is written by a lier? If it was a fiction book, but it is claimed as a true story experienced by the author.
For the beginning the small archive note- Slavomir Rawitz, though he was a prisoner of war, was pardoned and freed in 1942. He joined the Polish devision of a Red Army. He was never in the camp, he was never in Siberia.
Now, why the story is fake? I know Siberia, I know reality, I know desert climate.
1). He says in the book that they were transported in sheep trucks from Moscow to Siberia, where they were put so tight, they were standing without even moving their hands. The journey was for over three weeks. It is physically impossible for a human being to stand for three weeks, their legs would be puffed to death threat. And then he describes how they walked to the camp in Siberian winter after this journey, hardly dressed. Impossible.
2). In the camp (oh, by the way camp 303 never existed in Siberia. Archive note- camp 303 was somewhere not far from Moscow), the author worked making skis. In one day they produced a pair of ready to use skis. Lie. Do you know how much time it is needed for timber to be ready for skis?
3). NO wife of a camp authority would help a prisoner to escape. Only those who DO NOT know the soviet reality can believe in this nonsense.
4) He describes how they made a hole in the ice of The Lena river (in April!) with a piece of log. Ice in Lena river in April is 6 feet deep! Dahhhh!
5). He describes how he fell under the water when ice broke. He got out, squeezed water off the heavy winter clothes, put wet winter clothes back and continued running. Impossible. Impossible to squeeze water out of a coat in winter- and a coat would be solid frozen like a tin. Impossible to run in wet clothes in Siberian winter.
6). He describes blooming Siberian orchards in May, blooming cherry and apricot trees. What a stupid lie for stupid believers. Cherry and apricot trees NEVER EVER can be found in Siberia, especially blooming in MAY. Spring comes in Siberia around June. Apricots grow in hot Middle Asia. Dahhhhhh.
7) Mongolian gave then peanuts. hahahahahaha. They didn't know what peanuts are at that time in Mongolia. There was no imported goodies yet at that time.
8). crossing desert Gobi in summer, without water. In two-three days they would be dehydrated to death. Burnt by the sun.
9) meeting Yeti- oh, well, probably the only truth in the book. LOL.
10) The author never saw again the people with whom he made this journey.... never reunited? Only because there were NO those people. As there WAS NO such a journey.
Bad fiction, for those who would believe any lie.
Never take anything for granted! Question everything!
P.S. If you want to read about soviet concentration camps reality- read a book by Alexander Solzhenitsyn "One day in life of Ivan Denisovich".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No