3.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent capture of Ottoman Culture, Mar 9 2004
This review is from: Lords Of The Horizons: A fHistory Of The Ottoman Empire (Paperback)
The reviews here seem to be mixed between those who absolutely detested it, and those who love it. I find myself in the middle. As a history it falls short, but Goodwin is not a historian, nor is it (desspite the title) designed to be a history per se.
There were certain aspects of the writer's work I find irritating. He makes more than a few rather "arch" references- most of which I got (as I have always had a thing for the Ottomans, and have read most of the major books about them), some of which I didn't. The ones I didn't get the author didn't make clear enough to pursue through other sources- so the reader with serious historical interest is left hanging. This is the greatest flaw of the book.
The best point of the book, and the one which makes it a worthwile read, is the excellent way the author makes Ottoman culture come alive. He gives the reader a real sense of what it was to be an Ottoman, or at the very least to have lived among them. His description of physical places is good as well, he really captures the essence of places such as Topkapi. Even though I had been there years before reading the book, his metaphorical comparison of it to a camp of war tents made in stone articulated well the feel of the place, which I had sensed incoherently, but was made plaiin when I read it.
Utimately, the book is frustrating because it is merely good, whereas in certain instances it has flashes of greatness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Good Book is a Nice Memory, Sep 28 2002
This review is from: Lords Of The Horizons: A fHistory Of The Ottoman Empire (Paperback)
To be truthful, the subtitle to this book should be something like "An Introduction to the History of the Ottoman Empire" The author tells the story in a rather chaotic fashion, not professional historian-like. I should know. I have been "teaching" "history" at a small college in the SW for over 30 years. So, when I say "history this is not," it is not something that I would think of as a professionally written/styled history book. It is better than that. It is a story of the history. It seems to have all the "high spots," but it tells them in a catching, romantic, and very readable style. It is better than history. It comes close to being good literature. --no, great literature. OK, so it is not great literature... Before reading this book I had not so much as touched anything on the Ottoman Empire. This book made me want to know more. It is good. Good Good Good
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
A beginning to further studies, Oct 21 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Lords Of The Horizons: A fHistory Of The Ottoman Empire (Paperback)
Not be used as a study guide the book was wonderfull reading and gives you an idea of what the Ottomans were about.I would recommend this to anyone who is at the beginning of an exploration of the Ottoman empire. Some every day living details are pretty inaccurate but what the heck... you dont remember those parts at the end of the book anyway :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No